Phillies: Low Cost Catchers on the Free Agent Market


May 22, 2016; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Phillies catcher Cameron Rupp (29) rounds second base after hitting a home run during the second inning against the Atlanta Braves at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: John Geliebter-USA TODAY Sports

The Phillies already have a solid everyday catcher in Cameron Rupp, and two promising backstops in the minors. Carlos Ruiz and A.J. Ellis both spent time as a backup veteran for the team last year, so there’s reason to believe the team will look for a replacement on the free agent market.

Cameron Rupp played in a career high 105 games in 2016. He’s not expected to be the catcher of the future, that honor goes to either Jorge Alfaro or Andrew Knapp. Both could use more time to polish their skills in minors, and I’d be surprised if Rupp catches more than 120 games in ‘17.

The team could gain from having an experienced catcher to guide Rupp & co. Howie Kendrick seemed like a good pickup, but the Phillies could really use another veteran in the clubhouse.

Whether they bring someone back or go in a different direction, expect the Phillies to look for a catcher this offseason.

Here’s some choices:


Apr 24, 2016; Detroit, MI, USA; Detroit Tigers catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia (39) against the Cleveland Indians at Comerica Park. The Indians won 6-3. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-USA TODAY Sports

Honorable mentions

As usual, there is a long list of free agent catchers. Wilson Ramos, Matt Wieters and Jason Castro are the headline names in this year’s free agent class. They’re likely to cost a big-ticket, and probably want to play for a contender rather than the Phillies.

I expect defense to be the priority for the front office when looking for a backup catcher. That rules out guys like AJ Pierzynski, Nick Hundley, Geovany Soto, and Jarrod Saltalamacchia.

It possible that GM Matt Klentak would look at bringing AJ Ellis back. He received high praise in the Dodgers organization for his leadership, and a strong reputation on defense. Despite his weak offensive numbers, I expect a contending team to pursue Ellis for his advanced pitch-framing skills, and the Phillies will probably have to look elsewhere.

Dioner Navarro, Ryan Hanigan and Rene Rivera are all players that fit the profile, but their markets may be too competitive for the Phillies to be an appealing destination.


Sep 1, 2016; Minneapolis, MN, USA; Minnesota Twins catcher Kurt Suzuki (8) hits a RBI single during the second inning against the Chicago White Sox at Target Field. Mandatory Credit: Jordan Johnson-USA TODAY Sports

Kurt Suzuki, Minnesota Twins

This one may be a bit of a pipe dream, but Suzuki would be the perfect guy for the Phillies. He plays more regularly than a backup, but Suzuki’s defensive prowess and respectable work ethic will fill the void left by Chooch last season. He can set a great example for Rupp, as well as Knapp and Alfaro if/when either of them is called up.

Kurt Suzuki would cost more than the other options on this list, but his reputation as a great teammate and leader make him worth the extra salary.

The Phillies could simply acquire a player to catch 50-ish games and take his seat on the bench, or they could sign Suzuki: a player that will help teach these young players how to succeed in the majors.

For a very reasonable sum, the team could score a big win in the chemistry department.

Estimated Offer – 1 year/$7 million


Jul 19, 2015; Detroit, MI, USA; Detroit Tigers catcher Alex Avila (13) tags out Baltimore Orioles first baseman Chris Davis (19) at home base during the fourth inning at Comerica Park. Mandatory Credit: Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

Alex Avila, Chicago White Sox

Alex Avila is well-known for his strong defense, and his left handed bat is valuable off the bench. Much like Suzuki (and most catchers for that matter), Avila has often been looked to as a leader by teammates.

It’s easy to forget that Avila is only 29 years old, considering he’s already played in eight major league seasons.

Several injuries (most recently a strained right hamstring) have dismantled his once promising career. Avila appeared to breakout in his age 24 season, batting .295/.389/.506 with 19 homers (good for 4.9 WAR) in 2011. Unfortunately he was never able to replicate that production, and has been reduced to a backup catcher.

Still, Avila is a veteran backstop with playoff experience and a good reputation. He won’ cost much, and the kids could learn a lot from him.

Estimated Offer – 1 year/$3 million


May 11, 2016; Chris Iannetta (33) hits a solo home run against the Tampa Bay Rays during the eleventh inning at Safeco Field. (Mandatory Credit: Joe Nicholson-USA TODAY Sports)

Chris Iannetta, Seattle Mariners

Iannetta is the most likely of these players to end up with the Phillies. I say this for the same reason many predicted the front office would acquire Howie Kendrick, Matt Klentak knows him well. Iannetta played for the Angels from 2012-2015, which is the exact same time Klentak was working in Anaheim.

Last year the team acquire Peter Bourjos, and they’ve already picked up one former Angel less than a month into the offseason. He’s not much of a hitter anymore, but the Phillies don’t really need that from their backup catcher. Iannetta’s pitch framing has been consistently improving since 2008, which is hopefully something he could pass down to Rupp, Knapp and Alfaro.

Estimated Offer – 1 year/$5 million

This article originally appeared on