National Football League

NFL, players can't agree on mediation

Published Apr. 7, 2011 1:00 a.m. ET

foxsports

A day after the judge handling the NFL lockout lawsuit urged the sides to go ''back to the table,'' the players and owners both expressed a willingness to do so. The hitch: Each offered to meet for talks in a setting the other finds unpalatable.

A lawyer representing MVP quarterbacks Tom Brady, Peyton Manning and other players suing the NFL wrote U.S. District Judge Susan Richard Nelson on Thursday to say they're willing to engage in mediation overseen by her federal court in St. Paul, Minn.

And NFL executive vice president Jeffrey Pash sent a letter Thursday to another lawyer representing players, James Quinn, with a copy going to Nelson, proposing to resume talks about 1,000 miles from her courthouse - instead returning to the Washington office of federal mediator George Cohen.

Since filing suit in Minnesota on March 11, the players repeatedly have said they only are interested in meeting with the league to discuss settling the litigation. And since the lockout began at midnight later that night, the NFL repeatedly has said it only is interested in returning to mediated bargaining.

So Thursday's letters don't really represent meaningful progress.

''We are prepared to resume discussions as promptly as possible and to have significant ownership involvement in those discussions. Our thought would be to resume discussions under the auspices of George Cohen and his colleagues at the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service,'' wrote Pash, the league's lead labor negotiator. ''After spending the better part of three weeks with us, they know the issues, they know the parties, and I think we all agree that they were effective at getting both sides to look openly at each other's positions and try to find solutions.''

Pash also told Quinn: ''We understand that you will want appropriate assurances that the players will not compromise any legal position as a result of entering into those discussions. We are prepared to give reasonable and appropriate assurances to that effect.''

Cohen mediated 16 days of negotiations in February and March that failed to result in a new collective bargaining agreement, and the old one expired. The union dissolved itself, saying it no longer represented players in bargaining under labor law, which allowed them to sue the league under antitrust law. Owners locked out the players, creating the NFL's first work stoppage since 1987.

During Wednesday's hearing in St. Paul on the players' request for a preliminary injunction that would lift the lockout, Nelson recommended court-supervised talks, saying such negotiations should take place at ''not the players' table, not the league's table, but a neutral table, if you will.''

''This is really a matter that should be resolved as soon as possible,'' added Nelson, who said she would take ''a couple of weeks'' to rule on the players' bid for an injunction.

Nelson said she ''would be glad to facilitate'' negotiations, if the sides were interested.

''As class counsel on behalf of the Brady class, we think this is an excellent suggestion and are prepared to engage in such mediation without delay,'' an attorney for the players, Barbara Berens, wrote to Nelson on Thursday. ''Our agreement is, of course, contingent on the NFL defendants' agreement that they will not attempt to use this, our willingness to mediate, against the Brady class in some way, for example by arguing that such mediation efforts constitute 'collective bargaining' or otherwise arise out of a 'labor relationship.'''

Also Thursday, Nelson received yet another letter accepting her offer of facilitating mediation - this one from a lawyer representing Hall of Famer Carl Eller and other retired players whose case was combined with the Brady case.