National Football League

San Francisco 49ers: Pros and Cons of Hiring John Lynch as General Manager

Updated Mar. 4, 2020 3:24 p.m. ET

share

facebookxredditlink

Fansided, Peter Panacy/FanSided via Niner Noise

The San Francisco 49ers are going to hire former NFL star and Fox analyst John Lynch as general manager, per various reports on Sunday night. Niner Noise looks at the pros and cons of this surprising move.

Nov 3, 2016; Tampa, FL, USA; Former Tampa Bay Buccaneers safety John Lynch was honored at Halftime end inducted into the Buccaneers Ring of Honor during the halftime of a football game against the Atlanta Falcons at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports

Former NFL star and Fox analyst John Lynch is slated to be the next general manager for the San Francisco 49ers, as ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported Sunday evening.

49ers

Bolt Beat 9hNFL.com ranks Anthony Lynn as the No. 1 HC hire

More headlines around FanSided:

9h - Breaking News: 49ers to Hire Fox NFL Analyst John Lynch as General Manager, per Reports6h - John Lynch an unconventional, intriguing choice for 49ers GM9h - The San Francisco 49ers just hired WHO to be their GM?7h - Carolina Panthers: Thomas Davis' First Pro Bowl Testament to His Career8h - Cleveland Browns 3 Round Mock DraftMore News at Niner Noise

The move came as a surprise to many following the Niners’ GM search in the wake of Trent Baalke’s firing after yet another failed season in Santa Clara. Previous reports indicated San Francisco had narrowed its search down to three candidates.

None of those were Lynch.

According to Pro Football Talk though, Lynch wanted to keep his candidacy a secret. Hence the surprise on Sunday.

All this, of course, prompts the question whether or not this is a good hire. We can guess — and guess we will — but won’t know the actual answer for some time. Years, in all likelihood.

Lynch, and likely head coach Kyle Shanahan, will have plenty of years with which to work too. CSN Bay Area’s Matt Maiocco reported both 49ers’ new executives will receive six-year deals.

We’ll get into that as well.

Let’s cover those pros and cons and come up with an ultimate conclusion whether or not Lynch to San Francisco is a smart choice.

Oct 24, 2016; Denver, CO, USA; Denver Broncos former safety John Lynch during the ring of fame ceremony before the game against the Houston Texans at Sports Authority Field at Mile High. Mandatory Credit: Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

The Pros

When John Lynch retired from the NFL in 2008, he immediately stepped into the broadcast booth with Fox and stayed abreast of football action ever since.

This isn’t like one of those moves, let’s say like a Mike Shanahan hire, where a candidate has been away from the league for a while.

Lynch is certainly well respected in NFL circles too. And his likely Hall-of-Fame accolades lend even more credence to this new position.

Jan 22, 2017; Atlanta, GA, USA; Atlanta Falcons offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan speaks to media after the game against the Green Bay Packers in the 2017 NFC Championship Game at the Georgia Dome. Atlanta defeated Green Bay 44-21. Mandatory Credit: Jason Getz-USA TODAY Sports

The John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan Dynamic

Current Atlanta Falcons offensive coordinator is all but slated to become the next head coach of the 49ers.

And he already has a rapport with Lynch. Remember, Lynch was playing underneath Kyle’s father, Mike, when both were with the Denver Broncos.

Check this out, courtesy of ESPN’s Adam Schefter:

This isn’t a shotgun marriage for the 49ers either — no Trent Baalke and Chip Kelly combo. That didn’t work so well.

Hall of Fame and Super Bowl Talent

Lynch is eligible to be inducted in the Pro Football Hall of Fame this year, and it’s likely he’ll get the nod.

Additionally, he won a Super Bowl with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers back in 2002. Even if the Falcons lose Super Bowl LI, the Niners would presumably have two executives with top-level experience under their respective belts. That’s valuable.

A Big Name for the 49ers

FanSided’s Matt Verderame (I love you, Matt. But no) tweeted out the Lynch-to-San-Francisco deal was “peak 49ers.”

A peak move would have been a thorough GM search, only to end with a no-name scout or assistant being promoted from within the organization. Kind of like what CEO Jed York and Co. did with former head coach Jim Tomsula prior to 2015.

Tomsula wasn’t a big name. Lynch is. He’s respected and well known within NFL circles, as stated previously.

And as NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah pointed out, Lynch should have no trouble assembling a solid staff:

Next: The Cons

Nov 3, 2016; Tampa, FL, USA; Tampa Bay Buccaneers former safety John Lynch (right) gets a hug from announcer Gene Deckerhoff before Lynch addresses the crowd as his name is added to the Buccaneers Ring of Fame during the halftime ceremony of a football game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Atlanta Falcons at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports

The Cons

While the 49ers’ hiring of John Lynch is an out-of-the-box approach, the problem is this move is still an out-of-the-box approach.

Is that what San Francisco needs? It isn’t as if Lynch comes into this job with legitimate front-office experience. He’s never been in charge of a team’s roster before. And there are too many differences to count between a general manager and television analyst.

Zero Front-Office Experience

This is certainly the elephant in the room.

Sure, Lynch has stayed alongside the NFL in an analyst role for Fox. But that’s oh-so vastly different than an executive. When the Niners were interviewing ESPN analyst Louis Riddick for the same position, they could have at least taken comfort knowing Riddick had experience assembling pro football rosters.

Lynch doesn’t have that.

And, as Golden Gate Sports’ Sean Bialaszek wrote, none of Lynch’s player accolades will mean anything when it comes to making roster decisions.

Six Years Is a Long Commitment

Remember that part about both Lynch and presumed head coach Kyle Shanahan getting long-term, six-year deals?

Shanahan, well, maybe that makes sense. Remember, CEO Jed York is on the hook for both former coaches Jim Tomsula and Chip Kelly’s paychecks post-respective firings. A quick hook on yet another head coach is the furthest thing from likelihood.

Yet the Niners are equally committed to Lynch now. It could be Lynch was Shanahan’s top choice, which would make sense if we’re led to believe the latter will wield tremendous power within the organization.

But what if it doesn’t work out so well? What if, three or four years from now, the 49ers roster isn’t much better than what was seen in 2016?

49ers Still Need a Lot of Help in Scouting

True, Lynch could compile a solid staff of scouts and assistants. His big name alone should help.

But Lynch, as GM, would still make the final call on any roster decisions either via free agency or the NFL Draft.

How well versed is Lynch in scouting anyway? Keep in mind, prospect events like the East-West Shrine game and Senior Bowl have already taken place. The 49ers need plenty of help, and the clock is already ticking.

Nov 3, 2016; Tampa, FL, USA; Tampa Bay Buccaneers former safety John Lynch (center) stands for a photo with the Glazer family which own the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as his name is added to the Buccaneers Ring of Fame during the halftime ceremony of a football game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Atlanta Falcons at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports

And the Niner Noise Verdict Is…

Cautiously optimistic and excited about it. Sorry it’s not a one-way-or-the-other perspective, but that’s almost impossible in this case.

What is the case is the 49ers are taking a major leap of faith by hiring John Lynch.

It wouldn’t be the first time a struggling NFL team took such a route. Remember when the Denver Broncos moved Hall of Famer John Elway into a general manager role in 2011, even though he had almost zero front-office experience? Well, the Broncos won a Super Bowl four years later. That worked.

Oh, and the NBA’s Golden State Warriors did something similar with current head coach Steve Kerr. That worked well too. Lynch could be the next story.

Sure, there are a lot of question marks in place. But Fox Sports’ Jay Glazer — who is usually spot on with his analysis — is already endorsing Lynch:

Good enough for Niner Noise.

More from Niner Noise

Give Jed York credit for handing over power to Kyle Shanahan and, now, Lynch. The 49ers need that, even if plenty of question marks remain on the table.

But considering York and the franchise are willing to give both new executives six years to turn this thing around, it’s a sign San Francisco’s top leadership is looking at this as an ultimate positive too.

Overall, when in doubt, it’s nice to at least know the Niners are back to some form of relevance.

share

Get more from National Football League Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more

in this topic

National Football League

San Francisco 49ers