Week 17 takeaways: A grand fantasy finale

Week 17 takeaways: A grand fantasy finale

Published Jan. 4, 2010 6:08 a.m. ET

And just like that, the season ends.

It's just not fair if you ask me. The offseason is a seemingly eternal waiting game for September to finally roll around, and when it finally gets here, it finishes in a flash.

Sigh. On to the Winter Olympics, then March Madness, then the NFL draft, then baseball season, then the World Cup to help pass the time for these next eight months. Since there is no next week to preview, this week's edition of Takeaways is more of a glimpse of what to watch out for in 2010.

Browns 23, Jaguars 17

Jerome Harrison has had too much strong production over the last month for it to be accidental. He and James Davis should form a very nice tandem for the Browns next season. Running back is one of the very few positions for which this team has some decent depth, and with the two-back systems becoming more common in the league, Mike Holmgren will likely focus on upgrading other offensive positions in the draft.

• Don't forget Josh Cribbs in the RB mix, by the way. His fantasy value for next season almost requires a case study since the west coast offense which Holmgren runs doesn't really utilize wildcat formations. Not to mention, will the Browns have a new quarterback running this offense? Lots of uncertainty surrounding a supremely talented player.

David Garrard threw for 202 yards and two scores, which is about the best you can usually hope for from him on most weeks. I suspect things will continue to stay the same until the Jags get a true gamebreaking wideout on their roster. Mike Sims-Walker isn't it.

Bears 37, Lions 23

• This game was a bit of a bore for a while, then really got going in the fourth quarter. Jay Cutler's four-TD day will make his final TD-to-INT ratio look a little better for his inaugural season in Chicago and will hopefully give him a little more confidence heading into next season. Finding a top-flight WR would go a long way towards making Cutler a more consistent player. Every week, someone else seemed to emerge as Chicago's "new" WR1.

Matt Forte should start his offseason training regimen soon. Like, tomorrow. It's nice that he ran all over the Lions this season, but his overall production was a major disappointment. Right now, he's looking more like a late second-round pick - at best - in 2010 fantasy drafts.

• What do the Lions do with Maurice Morris? Kevin Smith was a disappointment on a weekly basis. Will we see more of a split workload between the two in 2010?

Texans 34, Patriots 27

Matt Schaub gave his owners who still play into Week 17 a nice going away present of 303 yards and two touchdown passes.

Arian Foster looked as impressive as any running back the Texans have fielded this season. He did his best to audition for a share of a split worlkload next season with 119 yards and two scores on the ground. Even when he doesn't play, Steve Slaton's value continues to decline.

• If Julian Edelman could somehow find his way onto a new roster next season, would he become that team's Wes Welker? Or is he a product of the Patriots offensive system? After Welker left today's game with an injury, Edelman picked up the slack and caught 10 balls for 103 yards.

Steelers 30, Dolphins 24

• It was feast or famine for a lot of Ben Roethlisberger owners as he threw for three touchdowns in four of his last eight games. Pretty good timing on his part since it was fantasy playoff time for many of you out there, but the problem was he threw for zero or one score in three of his last eight. Starting Big Ben was a volatile roller coaster ride all season long, but it was one of the best seasons of his career statistically. I'm not sure what to expect from him in 2010 yet. The Steelers need to address their offensive line if they want Big Ben to make it out of 2010 alive.

Rashard Mendenhall had a similarly maddening fantasy campaign since he was the type of RB who would rush for a few good games, then leave you disappointed when you finally took the plunge and put him into your starting lineup. But how will Willie Parker fit into Mike Tomlin's plans next year?

• Like last year, Davone Bess came on strong and had a few productive games. Davone, dude ... please carry that momentum into the beginning of next year. I'm begging you on behalf of your fantasy owners everywhere. Why does it take you so long to get going?

Vikings 44, Giants 7

• The Giants have been mailing it in for the last few weeks, now. So I'll put as much effort into my final thoughts for them as they put into the last few weeks for their owners: they are awful.

Brett Favre regained some momentum for the playoffs by throwing for 316 yards and four touchdowns before leaving the game late. Just an FYI to all the NFL head coaches who bench their star players in the final weeks ... this is what we'd like to see from everyone, and I have to believe the Vikings will function more efficiently in their first playoff game because of it.

Percy Harvin continues to emerge as a WR1, even though his build scarcely resembles that of a protoypical WR1. I'll be curious to see how he develops after one full season in the league, and whether Sidney Rice can continue to produce at such an insane level all the way into 2010.

49ers 28, Rams 6

• Now that the Rams have secured the first overall pick in the draft, I'll be stunned if they don't go after a quarterback. Ndamukong Suh is an awfully tempting addition, but a big reason the offense is so atrocious is lack of production from whoever has been under center. It's high time to upgrade the position, boys.

Vernon Davis continues to be a beast, and I can't wait to see how he performs in 2010 after such an explosive season. The 89-yard, one-TD game was a nice send-off for his owners. I just hope it wasn't the end of the line. He has my vote for all-fantasy tight end.

Michael Crabtree held out, then eased his way into the team's offensive gameplan, then started producing, then sort of faded off into mediocrity. Will he benefit from a full offseason training regimen with the team? Is he ready to step up and become the team's true WR1?

Falcons 20, Buccaneers 10

Jason Snelling was a beast in the final week. Sometimes, fantasy football can really be this simple: even backup running backs can prosper when they face horrible run defenses. Of course, when Michael Turner returns next season, all bets are off for Snelling. Turner had nagging injury issues that bothered him for most of the season.

Matt Ryan played better, but he didn't really improve as much as I thought he might in his sophomore year. Has he already hit his ceiling? Or would Atlanta's offense benefit from the addition of one more top-notch weapon (like a Braylon Edwards, perhaps, if the Jets don't try to sign him long-term)?

Josh Freeman's topsy-turvy rookie season came to the kind of conclusion most of us expected. He had his ups and downs while he learned on the job. As of now, I still don't think he should be more than a backup QB for most rosters out there. Tampa Bay also needs to sort out their running game and find a playmaker at wideout since Antonio Bryant is a walking injury risk.

Panthers 23, Saints 10

• I don't care what he makes - Drew Brees deserves a raise. Look at how poorly this offense functioned without him. Granted, Mark Brunell didn't have a number of weapons available to him today, but my point stands. And by the way, I hope for the sake of Saints fans that Sean Payton knows what he's doing. I'm not sure treating the final regular season game like a fourth preseason game is the best way to roll into the playoffs.

• Just like last week, Jonathan Stewart filled in for the injured DeAngelo Williams. And, just like last week, Stewart ran wild by topping 100 yards and scoring a touchdown. You have to imagine Stewart's fantasy value would skyrocket if he was some other team's featured back, but he'll still have chances to tote the rock by himself since DeAngelo can't ever seem to stay healthy for an entire season.

• Has Matt Moore earned the starting job in Carolina next year? He never really posted overwhelming stats, but didn't need to with such a potent rushing attack behind him. Moore will be another interesting case study for 2010. Keep an eye on him.

Bills 30, Colts 7

• Even though the Colts may as well have fielded fans from Indianapolis in their starting 11, Fred Jackson's 212-yard effort on the ground was mighty impressive. Even when Indy knew a run was coming, they couldn't stop it. Jackson hasn't taken the RB1 job away from Marshawn Lynch completely, but he just might if he has an excellent preseason next August.

Ryan Fitzpatrick throwing for three touchdowns in a driving blizzard is like you or me sinking a shot from half court in a hurricane. While blindfolded. On our knees. I'm still coming to grips with this statline and the fact that Fitzpatrick may actually start in 2010.

• I just have to ask - if you have no intention of winning the game, then why did coach Caldwell bother bringing Peyton Manning out at all today?

Cowboys 24, Eagles 0

• This scoreline doesn't even come close to indicating how lopsided this contest was, and what's worse is Dallas wasn't even playing at their best. I guess the Eagles decided on a warmup mulligan for next week's playoff rematch.

Brian Westbrook led the Eagles with 17 rushing yards. Brent Celek was a beast, but just about everyone else was invisible in Philly's passing attack. Yes, it really was that bad.

Marion Barber and Felix Jones eached rushed for 91 yards on the afternoon, although Jones needed one more carry to do it. When you realize Tony Romo passed for over 300 yards on the afternoon ... yup. This was total one-sided domination.

Chiefs 44, Broncos 24

• I've been saying Jamaal Charles is the real deal for weeks now. Hardly anyone in my big money league knew who he was when I drafted him, but if you don't believe in him afterhis 259-yard, two-TD performance against Denver, I don't know what to tell you. He may actually be a first-round pick next season.

Matt Cassel looked OK, but have we discovered that his ceiling is in the ballpark of 200 yards and maybe one or two touchdowns per game? Is he ever going to have the kind of explosive game we saw him have in New England?

• It seems like the Broncos are trying more and more to make Knowshon Moreno their featured back, and I don't blame them. Ever heard the expression "flatter to deceive"? That's what Correll Buckhalter does to his owners in a nutshell. Just when you think he's startable, he'll run for some pathetically low yardage total. Can we just pull the plug on him altogether next year, Josh?

Ravens 21, Raiders 13


JaMarcus Russell was benched midway through this season, and he came on in relief in three of Oakland's final seven games. He led a nice comeback in Denver, but wasn't able to pull it off today. I really believe the Raiders have no idea what they want to do with him next season. Surely they aren't going to go into battle with Charlie Frye as their leader, are they?

Michael Bush led the Raiders with 18 rushing yards. I can't decide if that's hilarious or tragically sad. Al Davis has some decisions to make for how he and his staff want to sort out their backfield as well.

Joe Flacco was woefully inefective in Week 17. It's not a good sign when Willis McGahee rushes for 65 more yards than he passed for. Flacco started the season on fire, but really fizzled out in the second half. Was he figured out by opposing defenses? Did he become scared of success? I really can't understand what happened, and it has to be terrifying for Ravens fans who are about to embark on another playoff adventure.

Packers 33, Cardinals 7

• It was kind of strange to see, but after Green Bay raced out to a 14-point lead, the Cardinals pretty much decided "Yeah, let's tank our last game of the season as well since we'll see these guys again next week anyway."

• Sorry, I think it's time to call Matt Leinart a bust. The offense just doesn't seem to respond to him when he's under center the way they do for Kurt Warner.

• Not much more to report on or speculate from this one, really. Neither side wanted to show all their cards for next week's playoff matchup. They, like so many other teams today, just went through the motions.

Chargers 23, Redskins 20

• Two carries for one yard for L.T.? Wow. What's even worse is that would have been somewhat comparable to his average day had he managed to rush for a touchdown. Har.

Malcolm Floyd had nine catches for 140 yards, and if he can carry that kind of momentum through the playoffs, we could be looking at a nice sleeper for 2010. I'm not holding my breath, though. Floyd has done next to nothing whenever he plays against another team's full starting squad.

• If Jason Campbell was auditioning for a job with another team next season, I think he's done a mighty fine job at it. Given the right system, he really could prosper. He's never going to be a fantasy monster, but how can you complain about a guy who will get you close to 300 yards and a pair of scores whenever his offensive line decides to block for him?

Titans 17, Seahawks 13

Chris Johnson solidified his position as the No. 1 overall draft pick for next season, in my opinion. He topped 100 rushing yards in every single game since Week 6, with most of them going comfortably over 100. Don't forget the sizable receiving yards he added more often than not. This guy does everything, and he's surpassed AD as the consensus No. 1 guy.

Vince Young was a hot pickup for a while, then sort of limped to the finish line. Every quarterback can get on a roll for a period of time, but the ones who consistently put up good numbers are the ones you should prefer to target in your drafts. Young will probably never be more than a servicable QB2.

Justin Forsett outgained Julius Jones on the ground yet again, despite receiving fewer carries. I have to imagine Forsett will separate himself from Jones early next preseason and turn himself into a solid RB1. These are the kinds of topics we'll visit throughout the offseason, and I'll be looking forward to your feedback. Thanks so much for following this season, and on behalf of everyone at FoxSports.com, we wish you a happy and prosperous 2010.

ADVERTISEMENT
share