Depth to be tested by Copa Clasicos

Depth to be tested by Copa Clasicos

Published Jan. 16, 2012 12:00 a.m. ET

This Wednesday brings the latest in the absorbing series of Clásico clashes between Madrid and Barcelona: a Copa del Rey quarter-final first leg at Madrid’s Estadio Santiago Bernabéu.

The tie is eagerly awaited by fans of both Madrid and Barcelona, as well as many neutrals; however, both clubs would perhaps prefer if the draw had not brought them together at just this moment. Madrid captain Iker Casillas let slip last week that so many Clásicos so close together (these two bring the total to nine in just eleven months) made each game descafeinado or diluted. Coaches José Mourinho and Josep Guardiola have both stressed that Copa is third on their list of priorities, well behind La Liga and the Champions League.

The timing of the games - towards the end of a hectic January schedule - is particularly awkward. Both face tricky league games next weekend, with Barca visiting big-spending Qatari-owned Málaga while Madrid host Marcelo Bielsa’s in-form Athletic Bilbao. The second leg the following Wednesday at the Camp Nou will be the seventh fixture for both in just 22 days, a run which is testing the squad depth of each squad.

By the numbers: Real Madrid


While only Iker Casillas and Cristiano Ronaldo have appeared in every La Liga match this season for Real Madrid, Sergio Ramos and Xabi Alonso have also logged over 1500 minutes played in the 2011-12 campaign.

Player GP GS MP
Iker Casillas 18 18 1620
Cristiano Ronaldo 18 17 1562
Sergio Ramos 17 17 1530
Xabi Alonso 17 17 1520
Marcelo 16 16 1389

Mourinho told reporters on Jan. 2 that no player would play every minute of Madrid’s matches this month.

“We are going to try and divide the effort between the players,” he said. “In January we have four league games, two in the cup against Málaga, and maybe then two more in the quarter-finals. The idea is to always play a strong team but make rotations, be balanced and for no player to play each game.”

That idea made sense at the time, but Mourinho has since been unable or unwilling to risk many changes to his first choice XI. Madrid's three key men - Casillas, Xabi Alonso and Cristiano Ronaldo - have played every minute since Christmas, with both outfield players performing well below their best. The Portuguese boss would perhaps prefer to rotate more, but he clearly lacks faith in Spanish international defender Raúl Albiol and home grown midfielder Esteban Granero, while former Bundesliga stars Nuri Sahin and Hamit Altintop are apparently considered not ready or not good enough to come in.

At 0-1 down in Mallorca on Saturday night, with Alonso struggling to make an influence, Madrid’s midfield clearly needed reinforcement. Sahin and Granero remained on the bench as Mourinho preferred to throw on all his attacking players and trust their individual quality would prevail. The plan worked, with Gonzalo Higuaín equalizing before José Callejón fired in a late winner, but the message that Real's back-up midfielders could not be relied upon was clear.

By the numbers: Barcelona

Like Real Madrid, Barcelona's goalkeeper and star have seen little rest. Beyond that top two, the Catalans have been able to shave more minutes in league from their players' odometers than their rivals.

Player GP GS MP
Victor Valdes 18 18 1620
Lionel Messi 18 17 1557
Dani Alves 17 15 1448
Xavi Hernández 17 16 1339
Eric Ábidal 16 15 1300

Barcelona coach Guardiola is also currently working with unexpectedly limited resources. His currently available outfield first team squad numbers just 13, due to new injuries to Pedro Rodríguez and Andréu Fontas, the sale of Maxwell to Paris St Germain, and the temporary exit of Mali midfielder Seydou Keita to the African Cup of Nations.

The Catalan side have rotated more than their Castillian rivals, however, with no player starting all four games since Christmas. To do this, Guardiola has turned to his youth team, with Barca Bs Martín Montoya, Isaac Cuenca and Sergi Roberto all starting the Copa second leg in Osasuna last Thursday, the latter even scoring the winner. “We will stick with these players to the end,” said Guardiola in his press conference before Sunday’s 4-2 La Liga win over Real Betis. “It is not a good idea to look to the transfer market, because new players have to settle in and it costs money. The reserves are the cheapest, most productive and sustainable solution."

It will be a surprise if either coach does not choose the strongest available line-up for Wednesday's game (allowing for Guardiola’s policy of always fielding reserve goalkeeper José Pinto in the Copa). Mourinho needs the morale boost that a win over Barca would bring, meaning Ángel Di María goes straight back into the team after a few days training and Alonso and Ronaldo will have to soldier on, for now. For his part, Guardiola is unlikely to ask Xavi, Puyol or Messi if they wouldn’t mind sitting out a Clásico.

Given the stresses and strains within both squads, though, the first-leg starting XIs are unlikely to make it to the end of the tie unscathed. And Barca look better set to cope with any eventuality. Should something happen to Xavi, Thiago Alcántara - a starter in last December's FIFA World Club Cup final - knows what to do. The idea of the overworked Alonso getting injured and the undercooked Sahin coming in is much less comfortable for Madrid fans to consider.

Nobody can be sure how Mourinho's men might react to yet another loss to their most bitter rivals, and a negative result could have knock-on effects for the remainder of the campaign, both in La Liga and the Champions League. Casillas' fears that the Copa draw has not been kind to his club may be bear out.