What a treat. The Predators and Blues have never met in the playoffs, until now.
Both teams punched an early ticket to the second round, Nashville sweeping the Chicago Blackhawks in four games and St. Louis topping the Minnesota Wild in five. This series has the makings of a potential goaltenders duel between Pekka Rinne and Jake Allen, but does it really?
Are the Blues as good as advertised or are the Predators the false prophets in this series?
Nashville ended the regular season with a 3-2-0 record against St. Louis, but the Preds didn’t have a chance to face the Mike Yeo-coached Blues until their April 2nd meeting — one St. Louis dominated with a 4-1 win.
That’s the one thing that sticks out about this series. While the Blues haven’t changed much in their roster, the presence of Yeo and what he’s brought since the departure of Ken Hitchcock has turned this team around to the one that dispatched Minnesota quickly.
Presenting a very similar game plan between the two teams, it could easily be an instant classic in the making.
Unlike Chicago, the Blues don’t have superstar names on their roster. Granted, players like Vladimir Tarasenko, Paul Stastny and Alexander Steen are extremely dangerous for a team like St. Louis.
Led by the first-round efforts of Jaden Schwartz, the Blues have a very similar offensive punch like the Predators do, but their depth is going to leave the biggest question mark.
During their first-round series against Minnesota, the Blues had plenty of issues controlling puck possession in the later stages of regulation and overtime. While their first-period efforts were strong in three of their five games, St. Louis was absolutely dominated in the second and third periods.
The Blues found enough goals and relied on Jake Allen to get them past the Wild, who just couldn’t score, but what will they do against a team that could dominate them in possession and creatively find ways to score?
Edge: Nashville Predators
Perennial Norris Trophy-worthy defenseman Alex Pietrangelo leads a solid St. Louis defensive group that helped limit Minnesota to eight goals in five games. Along with the talents of the heavy-shooting Colton Parayko and ironman Jay Bouwmeester, the Blues can stifle other teams defensively.
What’s concerning for St. Louis is the amount of shots allowed to generate towards Allen in its series against the Wild. Minnesota averaged 56.6 shot attempts a game against the Blues in Round 1. FIFTY-SIX-POINT-SIX! St. Louis didn’t crack 50 in any of those five games.
And just for comparison, Nashville averaged 52.75 shot attempts in four games against a much better Chicago Blackhawks team.
If St. Louis can’t find a better way of clearing out offensive chances and flurries, it’ll be in for a bad time.
Edge: Nashville Predators
And this is where things get a bit interesting. Allen was the star of the show for St. Louis in the first round, stopping 174 of 182 shots — providing him with a 0.956 save percentage and a 1.47 goals-against average.
The only goaltender better in the first round was Rinne.
Rinne’s 0.70 goals-against average, 0.976 save percentage, two shutouts and 4-0-0 record were tops across the league.
So, who will break first? Rinne allowed only three goals on 126 shot attempts all series long against a Blackhawks team that has some of the deadliest weapons in the NHL. Not all of that can be credited to Rinne, though, as Nashville’s skaters did a fantastic job of allowing him to see the bulk of the shots sent his way. Yet, Rinne made key saves when he needed to.
Allen did the same. It could easily be a low scoring, goaltenders duel in this series, featuring one-goal victories and possibly multiple overtimes.
But no one’s wanting that now, are they?
As the Predators had trouble generating any type of power-play goals in the first round against Chicago, the Blues had difficulties of their own. St. Louis only scored once on 15 separate power play attempts against the Wild. To a degree, that seems more lifeless than Nashville’s one power-play goal on eight attempts.
Regardless of how you look at it, both leave much to be desired.
In terms of successful penalty kills, Nashville had a bit less success than the Blues, allowing two power-play goals on nine attempts for the Blackhawks while St. Louis killed off 15 of 18 attempts for Minnesota — two of the three power-play goals for the Wild coming in the series-deciding Game Five.
Special teams may not decide this series, but if one team can be a bit more advantageous than the other when a man-up, it’s not going to hurt their chances.
Eight of Peter Laviolette’s players scored against the Blackhawks in the first round, and 15 had at least one point . Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports
Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports
With St. Louis muddling around midway through the season, Hitchcock was given his pink slip in favor of Yeo who helped it finish with a 22-8-2 through the regular season and tacked on another four wins in the first five games of the postseason.
Yeo’s done a masterful job guiding the Blues down the home stretch and outcoached veteran Bruce Boudreau in eliminating his former team, but getting past the second round is something that Yeo has yet to do in his coaching career.
Three straight times Yeo took Minnesota to the playoffs and three straight times they were bounced by the Blackhawks — twice coming in the second round.
Predators head coach Peter Laviolette has done this a time or two. He’s seen a couple of Stanley Cup Finals, winning one with the Carolina Hurricanes in 2006, and he’s been coaching for nearly three times the length of Yeo.
Sometimes that doesn’t matter. Sometimes it’s all about the luck of the draw and the team that’s in front of your perch behind the bench. It’s going to be a fantastic matchup between Yeo and Laviolette, however after what Laviolette did out-maneuvering Joel Quenneville in the first round I’m not sure if Yeo can match up the same way.
Edge: Nashville Predators
As it was in the first round against the Blackhawks, it’s Pekka Rinne.
Nashville has found the ability to force a team like Chicago into submission and score timely goals, giving Rinne the cushion he needs, but the Finnish netminder is going to have to be just as good as he was in the first round to send the Predators into the unknown territory that is the Western Conference Finals.
If Rinne can maintain somewhere near the same level of play that he showed against Chicago — as winning four straight with two shutouts and only three goals allowed probably isn’t going to continue as the teams go deeper into the playoffs — then he’s going to have a good amount of success going forward.
If Rinne falters, St. Louis will find ways to capitalize and it could be another disappointing second-round exit in back-to-back seasons for Nashville.
X-Factor (St. Louis)
Picking Jake Allen to continue his stifling ways would be a bit of a cop-out here, so I’m going one step further and selecting the Blues entire defense.
St. Louis found ways to score against a shaky Devan Dubnyk, but they couldn’t stop Minnesota from chucking the kitchen sink at them every single game. Pekka Rinne is just a shade better than Dubnyk and Nashville’s offense will find a way past Allen.
The Blues must find a way to shutdown Nashville’s ability to push through the neutral zone and drive into the crease. It’s all going to start with the blue line for St. Louis.
Nashville will have a field day in the second round if they have the same opportunities that they had against Chicago. It’s imperative that St. Louis gives Allen the same type of time and vision that the Preds have allowed Rinne. That’s the only way this series doesn’t become one-sided very quickly
Even with both teams moving on into the second round rather quickly, Nashville seemingly offers more in terms of offensive punch and defensive prowess than the Blues showcased against Minnesota.
While St. Louis offers more size to their lineup than the Blackhawks did, meaning the Predators probably aren’t going to push the Blues around like they did Chicago, they don’t instill enough confidence to stop the Predators War Machine in the second round.
Maybe they’ll surprise everyone with more than they offered Minnesota. Maybe they won’t.
After what they did to the Blackhawks in the first round, St. Louis should be terrified by what it sees in Nashville: a stronger, faster, more mobile, better protected version of the Wild.
In a fun comparison, it’s like fighting and beating a 700-pound grizzly bear in the wilderness only to see that same bear come right back to life wearing a suit of armor and now running full speed at you while carrying two chainsaws.