What if John Elway played baseball ... or stuck with the Colts?

Published May. 7, 2014 5:43 p.m. ET

What would have happened if Hall of Fame QB John Elway played baseball for the Yankees?

Here's one possibility — Peyton Manning would have ended up on the San Diego Chargers.

Check out the video above to see our predictions on what might have happened had Elway given up football for baseball ... or what might have happened if he stuck with the then-Baltimore Colts.