Your All-Time Indians All-Stars

After a week of voting, we have our results for your All-Indians, All-Time, All-Star team. It was no surprise that the 90’s Indians were shown a lot of love in this poll. Though some older players were able to garner enough of a vote to earn their place on our Tribe All Star team.

Thanks for voting!

  • Jim Thome – 75%
  • Vic Power – 8%
  • Hal Trotsky -8%
  • Andre Thornton – 7%
  • Luke Easter – 2%
  • Roberto Alomar – 41%
  • Nap LaJoie – 40%
  • Carlos Baerga – 13%
  • Joe Gordon – 3%
  • Bobby Avila -3%
  • Omar Vizquel – 61%
  • Lou Boudreau – 33%
  • Joe Sewell – 5%
  • Al Rosen – 59%
  • Buddy Bell – 35%
  • Ken Keltner – 5%
  • Max Alvis  – 1%
  • Sandy Alomar, Jr – 79%
  • Ray Fosse – 12%
  • Jim Hegan – 8%
  • Steve O’Neill – 1%
  • Manny Ramirez – 47%*
  • Rocky Colavito – 47%
  • Elmer Flick – 7%
*Ramirez received 1 more vote than Colavito
  • Tris Speaker – 47%
  • Kenny Lofton – 36%
  • Larry Doby – 15%
  • Earl Averill – 2%
  • Shoeless Joe Jackson – 50%
  • Albert Belle – 42%
  • Joe Carter – 7%
  • Leon Wagner – 1%
  • Bob Feller – 87%
  • Cliff Lee – 3%
  • Bob Lemon – 3%
  • Others – 7%
  • Jose Mesa – 38%
  • Doug Jones – 31%
  • Ray Narleski – 14%
  • Chris Perez – 8%
  • Bob Wickman – 8%
  • Sid Monge – 1%