Norris Watch: Experience trumps youth

When Buffalo’s Tyler Myers claimed the Calder Trophy last year, it was just the sixth time since 1980 that rookie-of-the-year honors were bestowed upon a defenseman.

Goalies have also claimed six Calders in that span, which, from a pure numbers standpoint, is pretty remarkable given there’s obviously far more rookie defensemen entering the league each year than goalies.

The high-profile nature of puckstopping partially accounts for their unequal share of hardware, but running the year-end rookie award numbers does reinforce how tough it is for new blueliners to have an impact.

As for the Norris, no rookie rearguard has ever added that trophy to his case and that certainly isn’t going to change this year. In fact, it’s a pretty safe bet defensemen won’t lay further claim to the Calder this season, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t some fine freshman performances being turned in on the back end.

Start with a trio of dandy Yankees.

Kevin Shattenkirk has slowed since exploding on the scene in Colorado, where he had 13 points during a nine-game scoring streak in November and December. Still, the Connecticut native is playing nearly 20 minutes a night and has 22 points in 35 games.

Massachusetts boy and 2010 world junior hero John Carlson has 20 points, one behind Mike Green, and leads the Caps with a plus-13 mark.

And Cam Fowler, who grew up in Michigan, is helping the Ducks transition to the post-Scott Niedermayer world by leading all rookie blueliners with 24 points.

If the NHL handed out an award for most polarizing figure, Montreal’s P.K. Subban would definitely be a finalist. Say what you want about the youngster’s exuberance, he’s really stepped up when his team has needed him most. The last game Subban was scratched for coincided with the final contest Josh Gorges played before joining Andrei Markov on the sideline for the season with a knee injury. Since then, Subban has played 23 minutes or more in six of 11 contests and has two goals, six points and a plus-2 rating.

There’s a future Norris winner somewhere in this mix.


Top 10 Norris Trophy Candidates


Ryan Dixon is a writer and copy editor for The Hockey News magazine, the co-author of the book Hockey’s Young Guns and a regular contributor to His blog appears Wednesdays.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.