Patriots-Colts rivalry filled with drama

Since Tom Brady became a starter in 2001, the Patriots have

faced the Colts and Peyton Manning in every season except one, even

though the teams have been in different divisions since 2002. The

Patriots are 7-5 in those matchups, one of them with Brady

sidelined, including 2-1 in the playoffs.

Here’s a look at those 12 games between New England and


Sept. 30, 2001 at Foxborough, Patriots 44, Colts 13 – In his

first pro start, Brady completes 13 of 23 passes, none for

touchdowns, in Patriots’ first win of season after two losses.

Manning throws three interceptions, two returned for touchdowns,

and finishes with a 48.2 passer rating, currently the 10th worst of

his career.

Oct. 21, 2001 at Indianapolis, Patriots 38, Colts 17 – In the

last game between the teams when both were in the AFC East, the

Patriots cruise after leading 28-6 at halftime. David Patten

catches two touchdown passes from Brady, one a 91-yarder, throws to

Troy Brown for a 60-yard score and runs 29 yards for another


Nov. 30, 2003 at Indianapolis, Patriots 38, Colts 34 – The

Colts, who joined the AFC South in 2002, and Patriots enter with

9-2 records. Manning throws four touchdown passes, but Brady’s

13-yarder to Deion Branch breaks 31-31 tie with 8:36 left. Trailing

38-34, Colts have a second-and-goal at the 1 with 21 seconds left

but can’t score, with Willie McGinest tackling Edgerrin James for a

1-yard loss on fourth down.

Jan. 18, 2004 (AFC championship) at Foxborough, Patriots 24,

Colts 14 – Adam Vinatieri kicks five field goals in his

next-to-last season with Patriots before joining the Colts. Manning

struggles with four interceptions and a passer rating of 35.5,

third worst in his 219 career games, including playoffs. Patriots

win Super Bowl two weeks later.

Sept. 9, 2004 at Foxborough, Patriots 27, Colts 24 – Patriots

open season with comeback from 17-13 halftime deficit as Brady

throws two scoring passes in third quarter. Colts miss a chance to

tie the game on the final play when Mike Vanderjagt shanks a field

goal after making his previous 42 attempts.

Jan. 16, 2005 (AFC divisional round) at Foxborough, Patriots 20,

Colts 3 – Corey Dillon rushes for 142 yards, Tedy Bruschi recovers

two fumbles and Patriots continue toward their third Super Bowl

championship in four years. Colts have three turnovers, including a

fumble and interception on their last two possessions, while

Patriots don’t turn over the ball. Both quarterbacks have mediocre


Nov. 7, 2005 at Foxborough, Colts 40, Patriots 21 – After six

straight losses to Patriots, Colts finally start a winning streak.

Manning begins the game winless in seven games against New England

and throws for 321 yards and three touchdowns, two to Marvin

Harrison, as Colts stay undefeated at 9-0. Patriots fall to 4-4 as

they’re outgained on the ground 132 yards to 34.

Nov. 5, 2006 at Foxborough, Colts 27, Patriots 20 – Colts again

enter the game at 8-0 and remain unbeaten as Manning outplays

Brady. Manning throws for 326 yards and two touchdowns while Brady

throws four interceptions, including one in the final two minutes,

and has a 34.0 passer rating, the second lowest of his career to

date. Vinatieri makes two field goal attempts in his first game

against Patriots.

Jan. 21, 2007 (AFC championship) at Indianapolis, Colts 38,

Patriots 34 – Colts rally from 21-6 halftime deficit for 38-34 lead

after Joseph Addai scores on 1-yard run with 1:00 left. Brady then

takes Patriots from their 21 to Indianapolis 45 before throwing an

interception to Marlin Jackson. Manning kneels down on remaining

play; Colts win Super Bowl two weeks later.

Nov. 4, 2007 at Indianapolis, Patriots 24, Colts 20 – Patriots,

en route to 16-0 regular season, get two touchdown passes from

Brady in the final eight minutes to overcome 20-10 deficit. Colts

also begin game undefeated but their hopes end when Manning is

sacked, fumbles and Patriots linebacker Rosevelt Colvin comes up

with ball with 2:25 to play.

Nov. 2, 2008 at Indianapolis, Colts 18, Patriots 15 – Vinatieri

breaks 15-15 tie with 52-yard field goal with 8:05 left. Patriots

play without Brady, who suffered a season-ending knee injury in the

opener, but are 5-2 behind backup Matt Cassel. Colts even their

record at 4-4 as Manning throws for 254 yards and two


Nov. 15, 2009 at Indianapolis, Colts 35, Patriots 34 – Patriots

lead 31-14 in fourth quarter on Randy Moss’ second touchdown catch.

Colts make it 34-28, and Patriots coach Bill Belichick, hoping to

seal the win, gambles on fourth-and-2 at his 28, but Brady’s

completion to Kevin Faulk falls a yard short. Colts take over with

2 minutes left and, four plays later, Manning throws his fourth

touchdown pass, a 1-yarder to Reggie Wayne with 13 seconds left.

Vinatieri adds the decisive extra point.