Childress considered benching Favre to protect him

Brett Favre and Brad Childress enjoyed quite the honeymoon in

their first three months together in Minnesota.

The coach coaxed the quarterback out of retirement to play for

the Vikings, picking the 40-year-old up from the airport and

personally chauffeuring him to team headquarters to sign a contract

in August.

Favre responded with some of the best football of his life to

help the Vikings to a 10-1 start, piling up touchdowns and

victories that helped Childress secure a long-term contract


A day after their first public spat, Childress said he was only

thinking about Favre’s safety against a ferocious Carolina pass

rush when he considered pulling him from the game Sunday night with

a one-point lead in the third quarter.

“I’m watching, and I said, ‘Hey, you know what? I’m thinking

about taking you out of the game here,” Childress said on Monday.

“I mean, you’re getting your rear end kicked.’ Through not a lot of

fault of his own.”

After their second alarming performance on national television

in three weeks led to a 26-7 loss to the lowly Panthers, Favre was

asked about an animated exchange he had in the third quarter with

Childress with the Vikings clinging to a 7-6 lead.

“Yeah, there was a heated discussion, I guess you would call

it,” Favre said after the game. “We were up 7-6 at the time. No

secret, I was getting hit a little bit. I felt the pressure on a

lot of plays. We had seven points. So I think everyone in the

building was like, ‘They’re not moving the ball, they’re not

getting points.’ Brad wanted to go in a different direction and I

wanted to stay in the game.”

Favre remained in the game and finished 17 of 27 for 224 yards

with no touchdowns and an interception as the Vikings missed a

chance to put some pressure on New Orleans for the top seed in the


Childress said he didn’t consider it a “heated discussion,”

but rather “a stream of consciousness” that Favre did not take

well in the heat of the moment.

“What I said was, ‘It has nothing to do with how you’re playing.

It has to do with what’s happening to you out there,”’ Childress

said. “And again, there’s volatility and emotion involved.”

Favre was unavailable for further comment on Monday, as were the

rest of the Vikings offensive players.

“Obviously, he didn’t want anything to do with that, which I

certainly appreciate from his standpoint,” Childress said of

Favre’s resistance to the idea of taking a seat. “He wasn’t like,

‘OK, let me get my hat on.’ That wasn’t in his makeup.”

Left tackle Bryant McKinnie was benched after being dominated by

defensive end Julius Peppers, and Adrian Peterson rushed for only

35 yards behind an offensive line that had no answer for the

Panthers’ physical front seven.

With Peterson stalled and Favre on the run, the Vikings were a

season-worst 1 for 10 on third downs. After throwing 24 TDs and

only three interceptions in the first 11 games, Favre has thrown

four interceptions and three touchdowns as the Vikings have dropped

two of the last three.

The struggles were enough to make Childress consider inserting

the more mobile Tarvaris Jackson to see if he would have better

success eluding the Carolina rush, and make sure that Favre remains

healthy for the stretch run.

Favre, meanwhile, wasn’t thinking about the future and didn’t

appear to take kindly to the suggestion that he should sit down

with the game so close.

“It was the thought that I was having at the time,” Childress

said. “Usually children do that. They give you the straight stream

of consciousness all the time, appropriate or inappropriate. Mine

was more communicative. It was to stream some dialogue. I wasn’t

trying to get a goat. I was just telling him what I was


Now instead of being in a position to challenge the Saints

(13-1) for homefield advantage in the playoffs, the Vikings (11-3)

have the surging Eagles (10-4) breathing down their necks in the

race for the second seed and a first-round bye.

The Vikings play at Chicago next Monday night, then come home

for the season finale against the New York Giants before the

playoffs begin.

“It feels like we’re 3-11,” Childress said. “Can you feel that?

It’s kind of palpable for us in the locker room. That’s how we’re