Year after trade, Melo’s time as Knick falls short

Carmelo Anthony briefly had what now belongs to Jeremy Lin.

Madison Square Garden shook when he was announced. Fans lined up

to buy his jerseys, chanted his name, delighted in having the New

York native back in the city.

The happy homecoming hasn’t lasted.

The Knicks are a sub.-500 team in the year since Anthony’s

celebrated trade from Denver, and the New York Post even wrote

Tuesday that the Knicks should try to deal him to the Lakers for

Pau Gasol.

Still popular, Anthony is no longer beloved. Fans appreciate his

talents but question whether they translate to victories, writing

on Twitter they feared he’d mess things up once he returned from

injury to play with Lin.

Anthony tried to laugh that off, but the truth is he craves the

popularity of Lin, an underdog success story whom Anthony compared

to Rudy.

”I don’t see why fans (would) not like me. I don’t say I

wouldn’t care, I don’t care, because I do care if fans like me or

not. But at the end of the day I’m here to do one thing and that’s

to win basketball games,” he said last week. ”If people don’t

like it, then they don’t like it. I move on, I go on.”

The problem for Anthony is he isn’t winning enough games.

The Knicks were 14-14 after acquiring him on Feb. 22, 2011,

after going 28-26 before his arrival. They are 16-17 this season,

but 6-4 without Anthony.

Meanwhile, Lin is the winner, leading the Knicks to an 8-2

record since earning his first meaningful minutes in a victory over

the Nets on Feb. 4. Anthony strained his right groin two nights

later and missed the next seven games while the offense emerged

from what had been a season-long funk.

The better they looked without Anthony, the more people

speculated that Anthony, despite being the Knicks’ leading scorer,

had been the problem all along.

One person tweeted on Feb. 12 that he wondered if Anthony

”knows or cares how terrified Knicks fans are about his


Yes, Anthony was aware. And yes, turns out they had reason to


The Knicks lost 100-92 to New Jersey on Monday, as a rusty

Anthony shot only 4 for 11 from the field for 11 points. He said

afterward he was trying to play as the Knicks did during the

previous two weeks and reiterated his belief in Lin’s ability to

run the team.

”I want Jeremy to have the ball. Hands down. I want him to

create for me. I want him to create for Amare (Stoudemire). I want

him to create for everybody and still be as aggressive as he’s been

over the past two weeks. I want that,” Anthony said.

”There’s going to be times I have the ball during the

pick-and-roll situations, being a distributor, trying to be

aggressive. But for the most part, I want Jeremy having the ball in

his hands.”

Anthony was greeted with a loud cheer Monday, maybe even louder

than Lin’s. He was voted by fans to start the All-Star game –

though the TNT analysts announcing the picks unanimously said he

was undeserving – so he’s still got a huge following. He thanked

his fans Tuesday with a message on Twitter.

”Big shout to all my fans and the (Knicks) fans as well,” he

wrote. ”It’s been 1yr. Wow!!!!!!”

Still, it’s fallen short of hopes.

He wore a huge grin throughout his Feb. 23 debut Milwaukee, when

the words ”I was born in Brooklyn, New York” played across the

overhead video board to a raucous ovation before he scored 27

points in a victory. He doesn’t flash it nearly as often now in a

frustrating season in which he’s battled an assortment of


The Knicks paid an enormous price to get Anthony, surrendering

starters Danilo Gallinari, Raymond Felton, Timofey Mozgov and top

reserve Wilson Chandler, and that’s created expectations that are

nearly impossible to meet. He could have waited and joined the

Knicks as a free agent with their core intact, and those holding

that against him are likely the ones behind the occasional groaning

at the Garden when Anthony launches an ill-advised shot.

Lin, on the other hand, was a simple waiver pickup who had

already been cut twice this season, the type of guy that’s easy to


The undrafted Harvard guard has downplayed concerns of his

ability to play with Anthony, noting Monday was also the debut of

Baron Davis and the second game with J.R. Smith.

”We’re not in panic mode, because it doesn’t just work where

all of sudden people show up and you have great chemistry,” Lin

said. ”So we’re going to have to work through some struggles, so

as long as we’re all committed and buying in, we’ll be fine.”

D’Antoni and Stoudemire have also used the ”buying in” term,

and though nobody has ever said so, the hunch is always that

they’re talking specifically about Anthony. D’Antoni’s offense

flows best with quick ball movement and unselfish play, and

Anthony’s preference has also been to isolate and hold the ball

before trying to take his man 1-on-1.

Anthony has had moments of brilliance with the Knicks, such as

his 42-point, 17-rebound Game 2 performance against Boston in the

playoffs. His 20 game-winning or tying baskets with under 10

seconds left are second among active players to Kobe Bryant’s 22,

so the Knicks need him on the floor no matter what this season’s

results have been.

Extra practice time around the All-Star break should allow Lin

and Anthony to develop cohesion, and eventually New York’s two most

popular players might be just as productive.

Maybe Melo can turn Linsanity into LinsAnthony.

Follow Brian Mahoney on Twitter: