St. Louis Cardinals: Fourth Outfielder Candidate- Jose Martinez

The St. Louis Cardinals have said that they would like a versatile fourth outfielder. Is this candidate already on the squad and was he already on the squad last season too?

If the St. Louis Cardinals really need a fourth outfielder and if this man is not going to be named Tommy Pham, then should the organization look any farther than their own 40-man roster? I wrote yesterday that this candidate could be found by taking a risk on the young Todd Cunningham. Today, I shall focus on another internal candidate.

Let me give props to one of our readers- Justin Olivier- who pointed out to me on Facebook the fact that I was overlooking the versatile player that is Jose Martinez when I published my Cunningham piece yesterday. Olivier was exactly on-point and I am ashamed that I- a massive fan of Martinez- put Cunningham above Martinez.

How much of a fan am I of Jose Martinez? Let see… I was the one who broke the news of him joining the Cardinals eight months ago. I was the one… wait, that’s the only article I’ve written about him. So maybe I’m not such a fan.

I feel as though I have written more about him but am having a tough time finding them so please forgive me. Having said that, let me say that I am a fan of Martinez. While I might not have been very impressed with his signing, I was able to watch him perform in Memphis last season. In addition, Martinez did a nice job during his brief service after rosters expanded.

Let’s look at his minor league career numbers:



Report from Baseball-Reference.com.

.294/.354/.410 ain’t too bad for a ten-year minor-league career. And how about his MLB career numbers:



Report from Baseball-Reference.com.

Impressive, no? Okay, okay, okay, those inflated numbers did come during a mere sixteen at-bats but they at least argue for the chance to prove himself.

As a point of reference, let us remember that Pham has posted an MLB slash (over three seasons and 314 at-bats) of .245/.333/.455. Would you take the risk on Martinez over Pham?

As I dive into the defensive numbers for Martinez, let me remind you of the defensive numbers of Pham. Pham is noted as a below-average left fielder with a -1.4 MLB career UZR. He is noted as a below-average center fielder with a -2.9 MLB career UZR. In keeping fashion, he is noted as a below-average right fielder as well with a -1.5 MLB career UZR. When appearing in multiple outfield spots, Pham is significantly below average at -5.8 UZR.

To Martinez then. Martinez has appeared in twenty-two major league innings in left field and two innings at first base. In these small sample sizes he is ranked as a 0.0 UZR at first base and a -1.2 UZR in left. Noting these numbers, then, we should admit that defensively these two might be a wash. It is a little to early to make this judgement against Martinez noting the small sample.

All of this considered, I would 100 percent take Martinez at the plate over Tommy Pham. Defensively, however, I worry that Pham is the better outfielder, honestly. Let me say that I have witnessed Martinez’s speed abilities in the outfield as well as having witnessed Pham’s and I would have to rank Pham over Martinez.

Does this mean that I think spring belongs to Pham? Not so. I actually believe that Pham and Cunningham and Martinez will be very interesting names to follow this spring. I look to each of them to get plenty of playing time early so that decisions can be made later.

Want your voice heard? Join the Redbird Rants team!

Of these three, who would you prefer: Pham, Cunningham, or Martinez? If you were Matheny, who would you ask to lace-up and head to the grass out by the bleachers? Stay with us as we dive head-first into spring training tomorrow!

This article originally appeared on