Nicklaus: Ruling correct on Woods at Augusta
Jack Nicklaus thinks Tiger Woods got the proper ruling at the
However, he’s not so sure he agrees with the slow-play penalty
given to 14-year-old Chinese phenom Guan Tianlang.
Woods’ third shot on the par-5 15th in the second round hit the
flagstick and ricocheted back into the water. He took his drop from
2 yards farther back – contrary to the rules – from the spot where
he hit originally, and ended up making a 6. Tournament officials
later said he deserved a two-stroke penalty for the violation, but
”Could they have disqualified him? Probably,” Nicklaus said
Wednesday at a luncheon celebrating his support and that of his
Memorial Tournament for Nationwide Children’s Hospital. ”But
you’ve got all the best rules heads together and they said that
they thought there was no intent to do anything (improper) and that
two strokes was a strong enough penalty. And you move on.”
Nicklaus, a winner of 18 major professional championships to
Woods’ 14, spoke on a variety of golf-related topics from anchored
putters to renovations at Muirfield Village, which hosts his
Memorial Tournament next month and also the Presidents Cup in
Nicklaus said he didn’t blame Woods for not disqualifying
”People say, `Should Tiger have withdrawn himself?’ I don’t
think so at all,” Nicklaus said. ”If Tiger did that, he’d be
putting himself in a position of saying, `I’m above the rules.’ You
accept the ruling whether it’s good or bad for you.”
The 73-year-old Nicklaus wasn’t so certain about the one-stroke
penalty given to Guan for slow play during the second round at
”He’s in the eighth grade! The eighth grade and he’s playing in
the Masters!” Nicklaus said, smiling. ”And he gets a penalty? Can
you imagine giving a 14-year-old kid a penalty for slow play?”
He added, ”There’s hundreds of guys who are much slower
probably than (he was) and they figure out a way to get away with
Nicklaus said he undoubtedly spent too much time over many, many
putts over the years.
Guan accepted the penalty without complaint.
Jim Furyk, winner of the U.S. Open in 2003, also chatted on the
dais with Nicklaus before a large crowd at Ohio State’s student
Of Guan, Furyk said, ”He handled it better than most of us
On Wednesday during pro-am day at the Zurich Classic in New
Orleans – where Guan will be playing again this weekend – 2012
Masters champ Bubba Watson said perhaps more penalties need to be
handed out for slow play on tour.
”I think that – not just the Masters – I think there’s times on
the PGA Tour where it should have happened before. I think we
should always give strokes (for slow play),” he said. ”It’s an
unfortunate situation because of who (Guan) it was. But again, he’s
not a pro yet, but later in life, if he becomes a pro, he’s going
to know the consequences. So he’s going to do better, and maybe
some other juniors across the world figure that out, that we need
to speed this up.”
During the Masters, Guan and his parents met with Nicklaus to
discuss the player’s future. Nicklaus had high praise for the
family. Nicklaus said he advised them to put his schooling first
and to allow the youngster to be a party to decisions.
Nicklaus said when he was 14 he was more concerned about where
he might take his girlfriend on a date, whether he could get out of
history class or would be able to miss basketball practice. He said
he welcomed the opportunity to meet with the family because it
keeps him in touch with younger players and allows him to pass on
the wisdom he had received when he was a budding star.
”(Bobby) Jones asked me to come down to his cabin every year
and I absolutely took him up on his invitation,” he said. ”(Ben)
Hogan asked me to play practice rounds with him and I took him up
on that. Even Arnold (Palmer), who is only 10 years older than I
am, did a lot with me; I learned a lot from him. It’s all part of
Nicklaus spoke just a block from where his father’s drugstore
used to sit on High Street. When he was a kid, the Nicklauses lived
briefly directly across the street from the old Ohio Union, which
was torn down and replaced by the current one.
On the subject of long putters, he said he was OK with them as
long as all of the ruling bodies of golf were united either for or
against them. He does not want to see players permitted to use a
long putter at one event such as the Memorial but not at the U.S.
Open a few weeks later.
He does not believe that a player gains a huge advantage with a
long putter, although he has his doubts about anchored putters
which might help a player stabilize the club more.
”Guys, these guys are so good, they can play with a
broomstick,” he said. ”They could learn to play with
Nicklaus said he played earlier in the week with Lee Trevino. He
said he hasn’t changed.
”No. Constant conversation,” he said with a laugh. ”We had a
great time. I love Lee. He’s a wonderful guy.”
Muirfield Village in suburban Dublin is undergoing an expensive
rebuild of its clubhouse before the Memorial Tournament, set for
May 30-June 2. Nicklaus, famous for constantly tinkering with the
holes at the course, said he hadn’t made any changes at all this
”I couldn’t afford it,” he joked.
Follow Rusty Miller on Twitter:
AP Sports Writer Brett Martel in Avondale, La., contributed to