Former Syracuse LB Cater wants another chance
Sitting solitary at a desk and resembling a soldier in uniform
ready for battle, former Syracuse linebacker Malcolm Cater spoke
ever-so-softly as he wondered about the future, that infectious
smile still creasing his face in spite of all his youthful
”I’m just ready to get home and do the right thing,” Cater
said during a recent interview with The Associated Press at Moriah
Shock Incarceration Correctional Facility, nestled in the
wilderness of the Adirondack Mountains. ”I want to show everyone
that the mistake I made was just a bad decision.”
Two years ago, Cater’s future appeared bright. About to enter
Syracuse University on a football scholarship, the former star
linebacker at Riverhead High School on Long Island had somehow
escaped a troubled past.
On a Saturday in May 2008, Cater bolted from a party that had
erupted into chaos, running from a kid waving a gun. Shots
reverberated through the night air and one struck the back of
Cater’s left knee, sending him sprawling to the ground.
So close to having his life snuffed out, Cater escaped and
recovered, became a captain on the Riverhead team, and signed with
the Orange over offers from several Big East teams.
Cater had a new lease on life and played in all 12 games in 2010
as a freshman, mostly on special teams. He was in line to take over
for Derrell Smith as starting middle linebacker for the Orange.
Great things were expected of the 6-foot-2, 225-pound guy his
teammates dubbed ”Clothesline” for his intimidating hits.
Then, in the blink of an eye, Cater was dropped from the team
after being arrested on burglary charges.
That checkered past – Cater was recruited before he was a
teenager to become a member of a gang and was ordered by a court to
spend time at a children’s ranch to steer him away from that
lifestyle – had come back to haunt.
`’He had a rough upbringing,” former Syracuse linebackers coach
Dan Conley said. ”When guys come here, it’s like they get a clean
slate. As a coach and a father, you’d hope that those kind of guys
that didn’t have everything that everybody else had growing up
would kind of see the light.”
Cater didn’t. He pleaded guilty last September to three counts
of third-degree burglary involving three separate break-ins at
apartments on the Syracuse University campus. One of those thefts
netted him a television. It belonged to teammate Ryan Nassib, the
Orange’s starting quarterback.
It was a stunning disappointment for head coach Doug
”If I lose a player for any circumstance, I look at myself and
say, `How did I let that player down? Did I do everything I
possibly could have done … to make sure that player was
successful?”’ Marrone said. ”If I have, and we feel we have as a
staff and as a program, that’s all we can do, and we need to make
sure we don’t make the same mistake twice.”
Cater remains despondent.
”He (Marrone) really kept his promise. He said he was going to
take care of me,” said Cater, who was given a birthday cake in
preseason practice just before the start of his freshman year. ”He
did the best he could. He showed me the utmost love that any man
could show a young man. I really respect him for that.
”I don’t know why I did what I did,” said Cater, who wrote
Marrone a letter of apology. ”It was one of the dumbest decisions
I’ve made. Being a kid growing up in a rough neighborhood and to be
put in a bad environment and getting through all that and getting
to where you wanted to be your whole life and then messing it up, I
just want to get home … and make it better.”
Cater’s uncle, Solomon Hatcher, said his nephew was under
pressure to get money for a son who was about to be born.
”I can’t blame his girlfriend. I can’t blame the kid. It was
Malcolm’s fault,” Hatcher said. ”Malcolm is a real good kid, but
he’s made very, very bad decisions.”
Cater has had plenty of time to reflect on his latest slipup.
Stunned that he received a prison sentence of 1-3 years, he took
advantage of a break given by Onondaga County Judge William Walsh,
who ordered Cater to serve the time in one of New York state’s
”shock camps.” Nonviolent inmates placed in these
minimum-security facilities live in a military environment and
undergo academic programming, counseling and extensive physical
That meant Cater would be eligible for release earlier than the
one-year minimum, and he responded much the same as he did at
Timothy Hill Children’s Ranch in Riverhead, N.Y., where he became a
tutor in a reading program for younger kids and chose to stay in
his room in a potato barn instead of returning home to all those
Isolated at Moriah and held to a higher standard by the staff,
Cater had plenty of time to reflect through daily community
meetings and talks in front of his fellow inmates. He also took
advantage of the chance to fine-tune his body, dropping 15 pounds
through daily 6-mile runs and countless hours of physical training
that have him ”in the best shape of my life; I can run all
”Reality hit,” Cater said. ”You have a long time to think
about your decisions and setting your goals. This program changes
you mentally and physically.”
Raised by a single mom with five kids, Cater has found football
a savior since he started playing at age 7.
”That’s what kept me out of trouble,” he said.
And football is what he hopes will rescue him one more time. He
was released earlier this month and is back home pondering his next
move, whether it’s trying to return to Syracuse – click on Cater’s
name today in the archives of the university’s athletics website
and you’re greeted with a blank page – or go somewhere else.
According to the student handbook at Syracuse University,
students under indefinite suspension are permitted after a
prescribed period of separation to submit a petition demonstrating
good citizenship in the time away from the university and potential
for making positive contributions in the future. A petition has to
include a personal essay and documentation of the completion of
substantial service to the community.
Soon to be 21, Cater realizes he faces an uphill struggle given
the chances that he’s squandered and the accompanying skepticism
he’ll face. He still plans to persevere.
”It kills me because I’m always reminded of it every day,”
Cater said. ”All I want to do is fix it. This is going to be my
last opportunity to make everything right. I want to be able to
show the world that I’m better. I want to get back on that field.
I’ll die trying to make it happen. Just give me a chance.”