Hall of Fame referee Arthur Mercante dead at 90
Hall of Fame boxing referee Arthur Mercante, the third man in
the ring for the first Ali-Frazier fight and more than a hundred
other world title bouts, died Saturday. He was 90.
Mercante died at his home in Westbury, said Edward Brophy,
executive director of the International Boxing Hall of Fame in
Canastota. The cause of death wasn’t disclosed.
Flags at the Hall of Fame were flying at half-staff Saturday in
“He was a complete professional inside the ring and true class
act outside of the ring,” Brophy said. “We will miss our friend
and mourn his passing.”
The death of an icon in the sport quickly sent ripples through
the close-knit boxing community. Salutes were planned Saturday
night before Andre Berto’s welterweight title fight against Carlos
Quintana in Sunrise, Fla., and a Top Rank-promoted card in Las
“I knew Arthur real well and saw him just a couple months
ago,” Top Rank founder Bob Arum said. “Mercante was a terrific,
terrific man, a real gentleman, and he loved being a referee and he
really worked at it. He was always in great shape and he was dead
honest. You rarely realized he was in the ring because he was
generally unobtrusive and he let the fighters fight.”
Mercante began his career while serving in the Navy, referring
service bouts in the 1940s.
He became a professional referee in 1954 and, six years later,
was in the ring for his first world title bout when Floyd Patterson
knocked out Ingemar Johansson at the Polo Grounds in New York City.
Mercante would go on to referee 145 world title fights during his
career, which lasted just short of five decades. He retired in
The best referees are generally the ones who go unnoticed,
quietly keeping order in the ring while the boxers do their thing.
But not even Mercante could avoid the spotlight on March 8, 1971,
when Madison Square Garden filled to the rafters for the “Fight of
Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier were both undefeated when they met
in an event that transcended boxing, if not all of sports. Frank
Sinatra was ringside taking photos for Life Magazine, Norman Mailer
and Woody Allen were in the crowd, and fans filled movie theaters
around the country to watch the closed-circuit telecast on the
night of the fight.
Mercante’s full-time job at the time was working for Schaefer
Brewing Company, and he received a call from the New York State
Athletic Commission hours before the fight, instructing him and two
other referees to show up at the Garden. One of them would be
chosen to be in the ring, so that bookies and other unsavory
characters would not be able to influence the referee.
“Of course I was dying to get the assignment,” Mercante wrote
in his autobiography years later. “The minutes, then the hours,
ticked away interminably.”
Mercante finally received word he had been chosen, and worked
for the princely sum of $500.
“He was the third man in the most important fight in the last
50 years, and he reveled in the fact that he was, but he had so
many other experiences that it wasn’t singular,” said boxing
historian Bert Sugar, who considered Mercante a close friend and
wrote the foreword to his book.
Frazier won by unanimous decision, then lost to Ali in two more
classic fights that Mercante did not work.
Mercante, however, also received the call in 1973 to referee the
title fight between Frazier and George Foreman in Kingston,
Jamaica. Remembered for the dramatic call by Howard Cosell – “Down
goes Frazier! Down goes Frazier!” – it was Mercante who ended the
carnage in the second round, after Foreman had dropped the champion
an astonishing six times.
Mercante also was in the ring in September 1976 when Ali fought
Ken Norton in what eventually was the final bout at the old Yankee
Stadium. Mercante kept control in the ring, even though the fight
was a dreadful bore, while a police strike allowed for chaos
outside of it.
“A lot of the officials today are in trouble because they do
not have experience,” Mercante said in June 1995, when he was
inducted into the Hall of Fame.
“They are putting referees in championship matches before they
pay their dues. They are putting judges in who have not had the
experience. This is the reason there are so many bad decisions. No
dishonesty, believe me. It’s just incompetence.”
Perhaps that is why Mercante was so pleased that his son, Arthur
Jr., followed in his footsteps in becoming a referee. Arthur
Mercante Jr. has worked his share of high-profile bouts, including
the controversial draw in 1999 between Evander Holyfield and Lennox
Lewis at the Garden.
“I think he took great pride that his son followed him into the
business and has done so well,” Sugar said. “I mean, boxing is
not a great tradition of father-sons. It’s not like a clothing
store or something of that ilk. But Arthur took great pride in the
fact that Arthur Mercante Jr. picked up where he left off.
“He will never be as famous or well thought of as his father,
through no fault of his own, because his father was one of the