Defensive Report – Claiborne starts to emerge

It is truly the most extreme of situations when you concede 16 points in the first 16 minutes of the game, and yet, you feel that the defense has done a strong job at minimizing damage.  But, that is the case on Sunday when 3 of the 4 Giants’ early scoring drives started at or inside the Dallas 31 yard line.

Turnovers caused what the coaches refer to as “sudden change” and to the Cowboys credit, they responded well enough to keep the team within striking distance.  And that continued later in the game when two 4th Quarter Giants’ drives were just for 3 points as opposed to the 7 that would have ended the team’s chances.

The defensive philosophy on Sunday emerged into a very curious one based on the success that the Giants were having (or in this case, not having).  New York was not moving the ball well, and so Dallas seemed to play more as an accomplice to the crime, as opposed to any sort of driving force.

They hardly applied pressure to Eli Manning again.  Just 1 sack, and even that was more of a situation where DeMarcus Ware gobbled up Manning after Eli was flushed up in the pocket.  In his final visit to Texas Stadium in 2008, Manning was sacked 8 times by the Dallas front (1 sack every 5.3 attempts).  Now, after 8 games since that incident, the Cowboys have finally matched those 8 sacks – but in 295 pass attempts (1 sack every 37 attempts).  

But, in the past, we have seen the Cowboys try everything else they could think of to try to get to Eli with blitzes.  However, in 2012, we have not seen this.  And on Sunday, it was the most extreme numbers to date.  We only found 2 times in the game where the Cowboys brought a blitzer in 31 passing situations (6%).  Given that we now have 2 meetings between the teams since the Cowboys have signed their 2 new corners, we seem to have evidence here that this is how Rob Ryan believes you can minimize damage against the Giants.

And, through those 2 meetings, one could admit that the strength of the Giants attack has been dulled from the last few years.  Victor Cruz has been ineffective, the running game has not bothered Dallas much, and overall, they did not find a normal number of plays down the field of the explosive variety.  The Giants had been averaging a league-leading 5 explosives per game.  On this day, they only had 2.  Of course, they didn’t need many given the generosity of the Cowboys offense.

It is fair to say that the two top performers defensively were Jay Ratliff and Morris Claiborne.  Both affected the game with frequent plays of note, and Ratliff troubled the interior of the Giants line all afternoon.  As for Claiborne, it is early, but he sure seems like he might possess that rare strain that everyone hopes for in the NFL, and that is he might be a ball hawk.

The ball hawk is very hard to find, but after years of tracking those types of takeaways – interceptions, strips – it appears clear that it is something that a player either possesses or doesn’t.  Charles Tillman, Ed Reed, Charles Woodson, Antoine Winfield, and Troy Polamalu all are of that species, and some of those players have changed teams and have still been great at taking the ball away.  It doesn’t seem to be a trait that is learned, although coaches talk like it can be taught.

Regardless of whether you think it can be emphasized and improved upon (I have not seen statistical data to support that), it does seem desirable to acquire players who look to take the ball.  And now, 2 months into his career as a professional, we are starting to see signs that Mo could be that type of guy.

Each week, we see plays where Claiborne is around the ball.  And then, we see him come up with it.  As a rookie, that is most impressive because that should be where he is most tentative, but with his disallowed strip versus the Bears, his interception at Carolina, and his plays around the ball against New York (including a fumble recovery) is showing me a pattern.  He is confident and has a swagger about his game that should get you excited.  They paid dearly to select Claiborne, but through 7 games, the speed with which he has settled in is most encouraging.


Let’s take a look at the “Splash Plays” from Week 7 vs the Giants:

Splash Plays are key impact plays from the defense.  Usually, they are obvious, but there are some that blur the line.  I have listed time and play of each one for those who want to double check my work.

For more, read a detailed explanation of this study here:  What is a Splash Play?


Q-Time D/D/Yd Player Play
1-14:16 2/8/O22 Ratliff Tackle For Loss
1-12:48 1/10/D23 Coleman Tackle For Loss
1-11:58 3/10/D23 Claiborne 3D Pass Defended
1-7:52 3/16/D45 Ratliff Run Stuff
1-2:17 1/10/O15 Carter Run Stuff
1-0:05 2/7/D13 Spencer Run Stuff
2-11:37 1/10/O39 Coleman Forced Fumble
2-11:37 1/10/O39 Claiborne Fumble Recovery
2-8:41 3/4/O31 Scandrick Pass Defended
2-0:49 1/10/O20 Ware Sack
2-0:31 3/7/O23 Ware Run Stuff
3-8:21 3/9/O22 Carr 3D Pass Defended
3-0:52 3/2/D46 Sensabaugh Big Hit
3-0:52 3/2/D46 McCray Interception
4-11:04 3/5/D28 Claiborne 3rd Down Stop
4-5:30 3/5/D28 Hatcher/Spencer Run Stuff

Sunday also featured another rarity for the Cowboys, a big hit in the secondary that led to a big play.  In 2011, I found just 1 hit in the secondary that broke up a pass (Abe Elam vs Philadelphia in December). Already this season, the Cowboys have 3, including Gerald Sensabaugh’s hit on Cruz on Sunday where Danny McCray picked off the pass from Sensabaugh’s rear.

Sensabaugh is not renowned for his physicality, and even famously passed on hits in 2010 on a few occasions, so to see him throwing his body around now is a sign of progress.  He joins Anthony Spencer (Seattle) and Brandon Carr (Tampa Bay) as Cowboys who have knocked a pass away with a big hit to the body of a receiver.

Up to date season standings – after the next game, I will make sure we get a “per snap” ratio:

Player Splashes
Ware 17.5
Spencer 12
Lee 10
Carter 8
Claiborne 8
Brent 7
Hatcher 7
Ratliff 5
Carr 4
Spears 3
VButler 3
Crawford 3
Jenkins 2
Sensabaugh 2
Scandrick 2
McCray 2
Coleman 2
Lissemore 1
Lewis 1
Church 1
Albright 1
Conner 0.5
Team Total 102



Blitzing played almost no role whatsoever in Sunday’s game.  It is clear the Cowboys want to flood the secondary with defenders to make Eli search for an open man.  And, to their credit, he seemed to have plenty of difficulty spotting that open man on this occasion.

Here are the two big plays of over 20 yards for the Giants.

Q-Time D/D/Yd Play Rushers
1-13:38 3/9/O21 Manning Pass to Randle, +56  4
4-14:46 1/10/O15 Manning deep to Nicks, +29 4

And, here are the two biggest Cowboys plays of the game that involved a pass rush.  Again, no signs of any sort of blitz.

Q-Time D/D/Yd Play Rushers
2-0:49 1/10/D20 Manning Sacked by Ware 4
3-0:52 3/2/D46 Manning Intercepted by McCray 4

Pass Rushers Against New York– 31 pass rush/blitz situations:

Pass Rushers 1st D 2nd D 3rd D 4th D Total
3 Rush 0 3 1 0 4
4 Rush 10 5 10 0 25
5 Rush 0 1 1 0 2
6 Rush 0 0 0 0 0
7 Rush 0 0 0 0 0

Not much to look at here, but nevertheless, here is the blitzing chart.  One should wonder if the Cowboys adjusted their plan based on the score, but honestly, your first instinct would be to guess that being way behind would result in more blitzes.  We didn’t see that at all.
The game by game pressure numbers:
Wk 1 – NYG: 11/37 – 30%
Wk 2 – SEA: 10/26 – 38%
Wk 3 – TB:  12/32 – 37%
Wk 4 – CHI: 12/27 – 44%
Wk 5 – BAL: 10/27 – 37%
Wk 6 – CAR:  9/39 – 23%
Wk 7 – NYG: 2/31 – 6%
Totals:  66/229 – 29%
It is all about incremental growth, and it seems that the Cowboys defense has done a pretty strong job through 7 games.  But, every week in this league is a test, and the Atlanta Falcons have a fantastic offense right now.  Having just watched them carve up Philadelphia with a very impressive deep-shallow game that utilizes the entire field, we know that Dallas will need all hands on deck and playing at a very high level of performance.

The Falcons feature weapons at all skill positions and will test the Dallas corners for sure.  But, it is pretty tough to take to much issue with the defensive job they did against the Giants in 2012, home and away.