Packers: 'In our best interest' to sit Rodgers vs. Cowboys
DEC 13, 2013 1:59p ET
GREEN BAY, Wis. -- Aaron Rodgers believes he's ready to play, but the Green Bay Packers' medical staff didn't agree. When it came to the final decision on Rodgers' status for Sunday's game, the medical staff won out, forcing the Packers to officially list their star quarterback as out against the Dallas Cowboys.
"Frankly, it's been a difficult morning going through the conversation with Aaron and Dr. (Pat) McKenzie," coach Mike McCarthy said. "(Rodgers) feels like he's ready to play. He's had a good week of preparation. He's very disappointed. He's frustrated. But speaking with Dr. McKenzie, this is the right decision."
Rodgers is less than six weeks removed from breaking his left collarbone, an injury that often takes between 6-to-8 weeks to fully heal. Rodgers has been practicing in a limited fashion for the past couple weeks, but the risk of further injury was obviously too great for Green Bay to sign off on.
However, McCarthy revealed that Rodgers did not have a scan of his collarbone Friday. Therefore, the last time that a known scan on Rodgers was done was Dec. 3.
"The hurdle that I know Aaron wanted to get over, he achieved it this week," McCarthy said. "He feels really good. He felt like he was ready to play. But listening to all of the conversations, all of the facts and evaluation, it's in our best interest as a football team, as an organization, for Aaron not to play in this game."
With the five-year, $110 million extension that Rodgers signed last offseason keeping him with the Packers through the 2019 season, Green Bay has millions of reasons to be cautious.
"I'm definitely OK with it," McCarthy said of the decision to sit Rodgers. "And frankly, I think if Aaron was asked the question, he wants to play. He feels he's ready to play. Based on what he's accomplished physically and what he was able to do at practice on Wednesday and Thursday, he's ready to go.
"Hey, it's not the easiest thing to sit there and tell your franchise quarterback he can't play in the game when he wants to play in the game. This is clearly a decision that's made in the best interest of Aaron Rodgers."
Rodgers previously said that he felt pain after practicing on Dec. 4, but in his comments this week, that pain level had reduced.
"I feel a little better than last week," Rodgers said Thursday. "Another week, to be able to relax over the weekend I think helped, and I'm feeling a little bit better out there."
Rodgers said he was holding out hope to play Sunday, but he added that he would need the majority of the starter's reps in Friday's practice in order to make that happen. But it was backup Matt Flynn, not Rodgers, who got all of the work with the starting offense Friday.
"I thought Matt had his best practice today of the two weeks of full preparation," McCarthy said. "(Thursday) was not our best practice as a football team, but I thought Matt Flynn was very sharp today, and he obviously took all of the reps."
This will be Flynn's third consecutive start. He signed with the Packers on Nov. 11 and become Green Bay's fourth starting quarterback this season. After Rodgers' injury, the Packers originally turned the offense over to Seneca Wallace, but he suffered a season-ending groin injury in his first series as the starter. Then, Green Bay went to its former practice-squad quarterback, Scott Tolzien, but he was benched midway through his second start in favor of Flynn.
Flynn struggled in his first start, a blowout loss on Thanksgiving in Detroit. He was much improved 10 days later, though, completing 75 percent of his passes in a win over Atlanta.
"My mindset all week has been that I'm going to start," Flynn said Friday. "That's been my mindset, so it doesn't really change anything (with Rodgers officially out). Just keep preparing, make sure -- our physical work's kind of in the bag, so just mentally I'm going over the game plan, understanding it a little bit more. Just making sure I'm 100 percent on everything that we're trying to accomplish."
Since Rodgers' injury, the Packers have a 1-4-1 record. With a 12.4 percent chance at making the playoffs, Green Bay (6-6-1) needs to win its final three games and have the Detroit Lions (7-6) lose at least one more game. The Chicago Bears (7-6) also have to lose at least one of their three games, as the Packers only shot at playing in the postseason is to win the NFC North.
Follow Paul Imig on Twitter