2016 Stanley Cup Playoff predictions: second-round picks

WhatIfSports.com predicts the second round of the NHL Playoffs.

Patrick Smith/Getty Images

WhatIfSports.com’s NHL predictions have been less than stellar thus far. We successfully picked the Capitals, Lightning and Stars to advance, but missed on the Penguins, Islanders, Blues, Sharks and Predators, a testament to how difficult the NHL Playoffs are to predict.

Undeterred, we’re moving on to Round 2. We played each matchup 1,001 times using our NHL simulation engine to determine which team has the upper hand.


Stanley Cup Playoffs: Second-Round Predictions
Matchup Win % Avg. Score
Lightning 51.0 2.2  
Islanders 49.0 2.1 Simulate Game
Capitals 66.3 2.6  
Penguins 33.7 1.8 Simulate Game
Stars 55.9 2.7  
Blues 44.1 2.4 Simulate Game
Sharks 63.4 2.9  
Predators 36.6 2.2 Simulate Game

The Capitals, our pre-playoff pick to win the Stanley Cup, are heavy favorites over Pittsburgh in the second round. Washington won 66.3 percent of simulations, outscoring the Penguins by an average of 2.6-1.8. In 1,001 simulations of the entire playoffs before the postseason began, the Capitals won the Cup 35.5 percent of the time, while the Penguins won just 1.0 percent of the time.

The predictions don’t get much closer than Islanders vs. Lightning. Tampa Bay won 51.0 percent of head-to-head matchups, edging New York in goals by an average margin of 0.1. The trend holds with pre-playoff predictions, when the Lightning were given a 4.9 percent chance to win the Stanley Cup, compared to a 0.7 percent chance for the Islanders.

Play WhatIfSports.com Games

In the Dallas vs. St. Louis series, our NHL prediction engine gives the nod to the Stars, with the team winning 55.9 percent of simulations by an average score of 2.7-2.4. Our original predictions gave Dallas a 12.2 percent chance of reaching the Stanley Cup Final and 2.8 percent odds to win the Cup. St. Louis had just a 3.4 percent chance to play in the Stanley Cup Final and a 0.3 percent chance to win it all.

Finally, the pick for San Jose vs. Nashville is the Sharks. San Jose won 63.4 percent of simulations, beating Nashville by an average score of 2.9-2.2. The Sharks were given the seventh-best odds to hoist the cup, doing so in 4.6 percent of playoff simulations. The Predators’ odds were much slimmer at just 0.1 percent.

Try building a team of players throughout NHL history and test your squad against other teams with SimLeague Hockey. You can play SimLeague Hockey for FREE using the promo code NHL2016. (First-time users only; valid throughout the 2016 NHL Playoffs.)