Rangers 2012 position players grades

The Rangers lead the league in most offensive categories; here are each player’s grades this season.

The Texas Rangers had an explosive offense when you look at the big picture.

Texas ranked among baseball's best in all the sexy offensive categories – batting average, home runs, runs scored, total bases. But if you looked at the individual players, those numbers didn't seem to add up all the time. The Rangers were also poor at situational hitting; failing to advance runners and getting them home from third with less than two outs.

And as good as the club was defensively; statistically one of the best seasons in franchise history, there were also some glaring areas for concern.

Here are the grades for the individual players. My grading system is simple. A's go to those who had excellent seasons, B's to those who were above average, C's to those who were average, D's to those below average and F's to those either need to give back the money they were overpaid or find a new city to play in.


3B Adrian Beltre The star student for the Rangers this year, Beltre was not only the team's offensive most valuable player but was also once again the best third baseman in the American League. Beltre did everything from playing his best baseball when the rest of the team went into an offensive funk and played hurt, something the Rangers desperately needed down the stretch.


OF Josh Hamilton One of the toughest players to grade. He deserves an A for his April and May and an F for his summer. He didn't produce when the Rangers needed him the most and was a distraction in spring training, the middle of the season and at the end of it. If the grade were for off-field performance, it would be an F. But because of his production, and few could match his statistics, he gets the grade. He can't get a C because there was nothing average about his numbers.

SS Elvis Andrus Andrus has career highs in doubles, triples and RBIs and may be the best shortstop in the American League. But Andrus may have tired down the stretch after also setting career highs in games played and at-bats. He started to argue more balls and strikes in September and hit just .233 in the final month. Andrus was again stellar in the field, giving the Rangers the best left side of the infield in baseball.

OF David Murphy – Murphy got more playing time this year than he ever has with the Rangers with manager Ron Washington's decision to start him against left-handers. He spent the final month of the season among the AL batting leaders but tailed off late. He had some key hits for the Rangers and finished with 15 homers and 61 RBIs.

OF Craig Gentry – At one point in April, Gentry had better power numbers than Los Angeles Angels star Albert Pujols. That of course didn't last but Gentry did stay with the big-league club for a full season for the first time. He ended up hitting .304 and was solid in the field. He saw his playing time decrease down the stretch as his outfield starts went to David Murphy. Still, for what was expected out of Gentry with the season started, he performed well.


2B Ian Kinsler – Still one of the most productive leadoff hitters in baseball, Kinsler didn't have a particularly productive season at the plate or in the field. It still was an average one by his standards and one that most other second baseman in the American League would take. Many fault Kinsler's effort, but body language doesn't equal effort. He scored more than 100 runs which is a leadoff hitter's job. He just wasn't as consistent as he has been in the past.

OF Nelson Cruz – The good news for Cruz was that he got through an entire season without being slowed by injuries, which is a first. But Cruz hit just .260 and set a career high for strikeouts. The Rangers kept waiting for Cruz to get on one of his hot streaks, but it never really happened. In 100 more at-bats than 2011, he had fewer homers and just three more RBIs. Once again, he made everything in the outfield interesting.

1B Mitch Moreland What we've found over the last three years is that Moreland is going to be a decent hitter against right-handed pitchers and not play much against lefties. So by that standard, his 2012 was average. His numbers were comparable to his 2011 numbers even though he had fewer ABs because of a hamstring injury. He hit just .239 against lefties but only had 46 at-bats. He was the best defensive option at first base but the other two were Michael Young and Mike Napoli.


C/1B Mike Napoli – He was on the verge of getting an F and that point could still be made. But Napoli is saved by a curve offensively. If you throw out last year's breakthrough season, 2012 wasn't awful by Napoli standards. But the bottom line is he was a .227 hitter who more than once in every three at-bats. Pitchers had a higher ERA when he was catching than any other catcher and he struggled to throw out baserunners (8 of 50). He also keeps himself from getting an F because he tried to play through an injury, which may have hurt his play.

OF Leonys Martin – You can't call Martin a bust yet because he's had just 54 at-bats with the Rangers in two seasons. But he failed to impress again this year, hitting just .174 in 46 at-bats. Martin is still just 24 but he's yet to have the kind of impact the Rangers had hoped for when they gave him a major-league contract last year. Maybe next year will be his breakout season. It wasn't this year.

C Geovany Soto – At least Soto was consistent. He hit poorly this year with the Cubs (.199) and carried that over with the Rangers (.196). But he did help the club when Mike Napoli went down with a quad injury. He was better than anything else the club could have put behind the plate. He threw out just 7 of 35 basestealers but the staff had a 3.90 ERA in games he caught.

UTIL Brandon Snyder – An argument could be made than Snyder could have earned a C based on expectations alone. But he gets the D because he didn't play well enough to stick with the club all year. Snyder hit .277 with three homers and nine RBIS, but had just one RBI in his final 27 at-bats before getting sent down and struck out 13 times.


Utility Michael Young – There are no bonus points given for being the clubhouse leader, which Young still is. But even there, the clubhouse didn't have the same vibe as it has had the last couple of years. Just looking at sheer production, Young had an awful year. He was put in a production spot in the batting order for most of the year and didn't produce. A decent September doesn't make up for an awful April, May, June, July or August. The Rangers didn't pay him $16 million to produce like he did in 2002.

C Yorvit Torrealba – Anyone remember a big hit that Torrealba had in his time with the Rangers? Anyone remember a key play Torrealba made behind the plate. No the Rangers were right to designate him for assignment after trading for Geovany Soto. While Soto wasn't much of an upgrade over Torrealba, the bar was set extremely low.

INF Alberto Gonzalez –
Harsh? Sure. But the Rangers thought enough to get rid of Gonzalez so he most of been failing. He only got 54 at-bats with the Rangers and hit a respectable .241. But it wasn't good enough to stick with the Rangers for an entire season. That's good enough for me.


1B-3B Mike Olt – It's hard to figure out which was harder for Olt to overcome, plantar fasciitis or manager Ron Washington's refusal to play Olt. He was supposed to get more playing time that he did when he was called up in August to play first and third. You can't just him on 40 at-bats, with just eight coming after Aug. 27.

2B-SS Jurickson Profar The Rangers didn't call him up to play every day and they made sure that was the case. Despite homering in his first at-bat, Profar got just 17 at-bats with the Rangers. The future is bright for baseball's top prospect. Just how soon that happens remains to be seen.

INF Luis Hernandez – Anyone remember the two at-bats Hernandez got this season for the Rangers? Neither do I.

C Luis Martinez – The third catcher for Texas, Martinez got just 18 at-bats this year for Texas. He did have two hits. All six basestealers who ran against him were successful.

Send feedback on our
new story page