Fantasy Fox: Post-draft rankings for starting QBs, 1-32
MAY 17, 2014 11:23a ET
Here are my inaugural fantasy rankings for this year's presumed starting quarterbacks (1-32) ... as post-draft minicamps open throughout the NFL:
1. Peyton Manning, Broncos
2. Drew Brees, Saints
3. Aaron Rodgers, Packers
4. Matthew Stafford, Lions
5. Robert Griffin III, Redskins
6. Andy Dalton, Bengals
7. Matt Ryan, Falcons
8. Andrew Luck, Colts
1. The odds of Peyton Manning matching or eclipsing last season's recordd-breaking tallies with passing yards (5,477) and touchdowns (55) are astronomically long, factoring in the Broncos' difficult schedule (four games vs. NFC West, four against AFC East, etc.). That aside, he's still the clear-cut No. 1 choice, among QBs, heading into the season.
The rationale: Even without Eric Decker (signed with Jets), Peyton's pass-catching crew of Demaryius Thomas (92 catches, 1,430 yards, 14 TDs last year), Wes Welker (73 catches, 778 yards, 10 TDs), Emmanuel Sanders, Andre Caldwell, rookie wideout Cody Latimer (a future star), tight end Julius Thomas (12 TDs) and tailback Montee Ball is absurdly deep.
2. For once, Drew Brees did not win the unofficial fantasy title of "Most Games Of 300 Total Yards and/or Three Touchdowns" in 2013. That honor went to Peyton Manning (13). As a consolation, Brees had to settle for becoming the first QB in NFL history to pass for 5,000 yards in back-to-back-to-back seasons.
3. I have Aaron Rodgers (2,536, 17 TDs for eight full games last season) penciled in for 4,450 yards passing and 42 touchdowns -- his two-year averages for the 2011 and '12 seasons.
4. Strange but true: Andrew Luck (3,822 yards passing, 27 total TDs) eclipsed the weekly QB-elite threshold of 290 total yards and/or three touchdowns just six times last year. And yet, the Colts still notched 27 or more points eight times.
5. Of his first 12 games last year, Lions QB Matthew Stafford (4,650 yards passing, 31 total TDs) racked up 300 total yards and/or three touchdowns nine times.
It's an encouraging sign for a guy who's always a candidate for 5,000 yards passing.
On the flip side, there is a clear line of fantasy demarcation separating Manning, Brees, Rodgers ... and every other quarterback in this countdown.
9. Tom Brady, Patriots
10. Colin Kaepernick, 49ers
11. Jay Cutler, Bears
12. Philip Rivers, Chargers
13. Cam Newton, Panthers
14. Nick Foles, Eagles
15. Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers
16. Joe Flacco, Ravens
1. Cam Newton has averaged 3,766 yards passing and 31 total TDs in his three-year NFL career; but the Panthers QB can only do so much with an underwhelming receiving corps that includes rookie Kelvin Benjamin (great athlete, likely not ready to be a WR1), Jerricho Cotchery, Jason Avant, Tiquan Underwood and Tavarres King. Ugh!
2. The Ravens might not have a single bad-weather game all season. Baltimore's last cold-weather road trip involves Pittsburgh for Week 9.
After that, the Ravens' final three road outings take place in New Orleans (Nov. 24), Miami (Dec. 7) and Houston (Dec. 21).
3. The Flacco ranking could be a bummer by season's end. Prior to his sparkling championship run two seasons ago (January/February 2013), the quarterback had never thrown three TDs in three consecutive outings.
For the 2013 campaign, Flacco tallied three touchdowns only once (Week 14 vs. Minnesota).
4. For the fantasy owners who end up with bad teams this fall, or at least below-average records, you may regret drafting Flacco, Tony Romo, Newton or Ben Roethlisberger as QB1s.
The rationale? The foursome won't have their bye weeks until Week 11 (Flacco, Romo) or Week 12 (Newton, Roethlisberger) ... meaning you'll likely have to trade the quarterbacks around Week 7 -- or risk the notion of starting Jake Locker, Matt Cassel or whoever gets the call for the Browns on a bye-ravaged, must-win Sunday.
17. Russell Wilson, Seahawks
18. Tony Romo, Cowboys
19. Alex Smith, Chiefs
20. Ryan Tannehill, Dolphins
21. Carson Palmer, Cardinals
22. Eli Manning, Giants
23. Josh McCown, Buccaneers
24. Matt Schaub, Raiders
1. Seattle's Russell Wilson may be sitting on a mountain of gold in the real world of big-boy football, but here's a dose of fantasy reality:
Of his 16 regular-season games last year, the Seahawks QB and Super Bowl champion tallied just zero or one touchdown eight times. Of course, having Percy Harvin for a full season would certainly boost Wilson's prospects of starting 10 or 12 times on fantasy weekends.
2. Consider Romo's ranking to be a placeholder during the summer months, while he rehabs from back surgery. When fully healthy, Romo has the capacity to be a top-12 fantasy passer.
3. How deep is this year's QB class? In 16-team leagues, in-their-prime assets like Romo, Ryan Tannehill, Eli Manning, Alex Smith and, of course, Wilson could be backups for as many as 10 fantasy weekends.
4. Don't fall asleep on Cardinals QB Carson Palmer during the preseason. He accounted for 4,274 yards passing (career high) and 24 touchdowns in his first season with head coach/offensive Bruce Arians.
Of equal importance, Palmer averaged 290 yards passing and 1.5 TDs against the dominant NFC West last year (six games).
25. Sam Bradford, Rams
26. Ryan Fitzpatrick, Texans
27. Jake Locker, Titans
28. Chad Henne, Jaguars
29. EJ Manuel, Bills
30. Brian Hoyer, Browns
31. Matt Cassel, Vikings
32. Geno Smith, Jets
1. Brian Hoyer's porous ranking goes on the assumption of a lengthy Josh Gordon suspension -- covering eight, 12 or even 16 games. It also presumes that first-round pick Johnny Manziel will see the field sooner than later in Year 1.
2. Ryan Fitzpatrick is no longer a sustainable starting QB in the NFL. In the short term, though, it's impossible to fail when Andre Johnson (109 catches, 1,407 yards, five TDs last year), DeAndre Hopkins (primed for a breakout), DeVier Posey, tailback Arian Foster and tight end Garrett Graham are your primary weapons.
3. The Jets have done a nice job of upgrading their playmakers -- signing tailback Chris Johnson and receiver Eric Decker as free agents and then snagging wideouts Shaq Evans and Jalen Saunders in the draft. (Don't bury Stephen Hill just yet, either.)
That aside, Geno Smith must prove his stripes as a viable fantasy quarterback. In his final nine games last season, Smith accounted for only 240 total yards and/or multiple touchdowns twice.
4. Matt Cassel (1,807 yards passing, 11 TDs) could be a nice sleeper pick early in the season, as part of Norv Turner's progressive offense. Just don't expect him to be logging any starts after Minnesota's Week 10 bye (Teddy Bridgewater time).
5. Consider this an unsung endorsement to consider starting Chad Henne during September: The Jaguars' first four opponents -- the Eagles, Redskins, Colts and Chargers -- ranked 32nd, 20th, 13th and 29th against the pass last year.
And lest we forget that Kansas City QB Alex Smith passed for 378 yards and four TDs against Indy in the wild-card round last January.
6. I'm not the world's biggest Sam Bradford fan. However, before suffering a knee injury last year, Bradford accounted for 300 total yards and/or multiple touchdowns in four of seven starts.
That's a respectable output, considering most NFL fans can't name four -- or maybe even three -- of the Rams' top-six receivers.
Jay Clemons can be reached, day or night, on Twitter at @FOX_JayClemons.