StaTuesday: Ranking Vikings coach Mike Zimmer
By at least one measure, Minnesota Vikings boss Mike Zimmer is one of the best coaches in the league.
Zimmer earned an overall rating of 7.7 out of 10 from Headcoachranking.com, which uses a proprietary formula to grade NFL coaches on five different attributes: play calling, game plan, clock management, personnel and in-game adjustments.
His individual ratings break down as follows:
Play calling -- 7.7 (T2)
Game plan -- 7.9 (1st)
Clock management -- 7.4 (4th)
Personnel -- 7.8 (4th)
In-game adjustments -- 7.6 (4th)
Click here for a more in-depth explanation of their analysts' methodology.
The fourth-year head coach trailed only New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick (7.9) and New Orleans Saints coach Sean Payton (7.8) for the top spot, finishing in a tie for third with first-year Los Angeles Rams coach Sean McVay.
For context, Hue Jackson of the Cleveland Browns -- a former colleague of Zimmer's -- and Chuck Pagano of the Indianapolis Colts tied for last with a 5.8 rating.
The assessment isn't without precedent. USA TODAY ranked Zimmer the second-best coach in the playoffs behind Belichick earlier this month.
The Headcoachingrankings.com crew lists Week 1 as Zimmer's finest hour. He earned his highest single-game rating of the season in the Vikings' 29-19 dissection of the Saints, registering a 9.2 on the site's scale, while earning a perfect 10.0 for his clock management.
He edged Payton once again in the playoffs, earning an 8 in play calling, game plan, clock management and personnel, and a 7.8 for in-game adjustments.
The site posits that Zimmer lost the coaching battle in the NFC Championship, however. He was outscored by Philadelphia Eagles coach Doug Pederson in all five categories. The site's analysts took significant issue with the Vikings' decision to try for a seven-yard touchdown on fourth-and-goal while down 31-7 in the third quarter.
Zimmer and offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur, the site notes, staked too much of the game on a single play instead of settling for three points.
"Although Minnesota needed several scores to get back in the game, we felt it was too early to start chasing points," they said. "The drive was effective, and by coming away with points, the offense has some momentum to build off of, whereas coming away empty handed shifted all the momentum back to Philadelphia and their home crowd."
Check out the full rankings below.
Coach | Team | Overall |
Bill Belichick | Patriots | 7.9 |
Sean Payton | Saints | 7.8 |
Mike Zimmer | Vikings | 7.7 |
Sean McVay | Rams | 7.7 |
Doug Pederson | Eagles | 7.5 |
Andy Reid | Chiefs | 7.3 |
Kyle Shanahan | 49ers | 7.1 |
Doug Marrone | Jaguars | 7.0 |
Jay Gruden | Redskins | 7.0 |
Anthony Lynn | Chargers | 7.0 |
Mike Tomlin | Steelers | 6.9 |
John Harbaugh | Ravens | 6.9 |
Jim Caldwell | Lions | 6.9 |
Dan Quinn | Falcons | 6.8 |
Todd Bowles | Jets | 6.7 |
Sean McDermott | Bills | 6.6 |
Dirk Koetter | Bucs | 6.6 |
Bill O'Brien | Texans | 6.5 |
Ron Rivera | Panthers | 6.5 |
Mike McCarthy | Packers | 6.5 |
Mike Mularkey | Titans | 6.5 |
Pete Caroll | Seahawks | 6.5 |
Jason Garrett | Cowboys | 6.4 |
Bruce Arians | Cardinals | 6.4 |
John Fox | Bears | 6.2 |
Marvin Lewis | Bengals | 6.2 |
Adam Gase | Dolphins | 6.1 |
Vance Joseph | Broncos | 6.0 |
Steve Spagnuolo | Giants | 6.0 |
Jack Del Rio | Raiders | 5.9 |
Chuck Pagano | Colts | 5.8 |
Hue Jackson | Browns | 5.8 |
-
2024 NFL Draft Schedule: Date, time, how to watch, TV channel
2024 NFL Draft: 5 QBs drafted, Jets add Bowers in Nick Wright's final mock draft
2024 NFL Draft odds: Jayden Daniels' second pick odds shortening
-
2024 NFL Mock Draft: Chargers, Giants land star wideouts after QBs go 1-4
2024 NFL Draft order: Every pick for all seven rounds
2024 NFL Draft QB rankings: Caleb Williams leads top 10 prospects
-
2024 NFL Draft prospect rankings: Top 100 led by Caleb Williams
2024 NFL Draft odds: Chargers' odds to pick J.J. McCarthy rise on draft eve
2024 NFL playoff bracket: Schedule, picture, Super Bowl result
-
2024 NFL Draft Schedule: Date, time, how to watch, TV channel
2024 NFL Draft: 5 QBs drafted, Jets add Bowers in Nick Wright's final mock draft
2024 NFL Draft odds: Jayden Daniels' second pick odds shortening
-
2024 NFL Mock Draft: Chargers, Giants land star wideouts after QBs go 1-4
2024 NFL Draft order: Every pick for all seven rounds
2024 NFL Draft QB rankings: Caleb Williams leads top 10 prospects
-
2024 NFL Draft prospect rankings: Top 100 led by Caleb Williams
2024 NFL Draft odds: Chargers' odds to pick J.J. McCarthy rise on draft eve
2024 NFL playoff bracket: Schedule, picture, Super Bowl result