Deaths of enforcers invite real scrutiny

Share This Story

Jen Floyd Engel

Jen Floyd Engel, selected as the top columnist in the 2012 Associated Press Sports Editors annual contest, started working at the Fort Worth Star-Telegram in 1997 and became a columnist in 2003 before joining FOXSports.com. Sports opinions? She's never short of them. And love her or hate her, she'll be just another one of the boys. Follow her on Twitter or like her on Facebook.


The pictures hang in my office. My favorite is the one in which Dallas Stars enforcer Krys Barch has a balled-up fist aimed directly at my face, and I am smiling.

Jen Floyd Engel got an up-close look at what a hockey fight is like.

Courtesy Jen Floyd Engel

The photos are from a couple of years ago when, on a whim, I strapped on my hockey skates for a column about enforcers. I have always enjoyed the role fighting plays in the game, defended its place, as well as those who do it. The idea was to learn the art of necessary violence while also introducing these oft-misunderstood athletes.

Barch laughed the whole time as he told stories of absorbing right hooks and delivering TKOs, or at least that is how I remembered it — or how I did until last week, when news surfaced that affable and funny NHL enforcer Wade Belak had reportedly killed himself.

His is the third tragic death of an enforcer this summer, and now my memory of that day with Barch feels fuzzy.

Maybe Barch had not been laughing at all. Maybe he was angry at my giddy enthusiasm regarding what basically amounts to premeditated blows to his head.

Maybe, as now-retired Georges Laraque acknowledged recently, he hates what he does — the punching, the emotional toll, the stress — but does it anyway because it is his only ticket into the league.

Maybe I had been wrong about fighting all along.

So I called Barch, and I waited.

The thing about fighting in hockey is that everybody already had an opinion, and now everybody really has an opinion. The deaths of these men has given a soapbox to those with an agenda, who may casually relate this to concussions or how the league handles former players or fighting. Mostly fighting.


Three enforcers have died suspiciously since May, leaving the NHL in the fight of its life, A.J. Perez says.

Non-hockey types have never understood why a real sport would intermittently stop for a brawl. Many friends have told me they would never watch as long as there was fighting. More than a few will not watch without it.

The allure of the fight is self-evident, much like the appeal of the crash at the Indy 500 or the vicious hit in the NFL. We love it. It also serves a role. Hockey is a game in which teams protect their own, where the mere specter of certain players helps protect the stars. The enforcers are almost universally the best guys in the league, and Belak by all accounts was one of those guys — funny and well liked.

“He hung himself,” said Mike Modano, most recently of the Detroit Red Wings. “Did you see that?”

I have known Modano — the highest-scoring American-born player in NHL history — for 10-plus years. He is one of the most laid-back, irreverent, unflappable athletes I have dealt with. But after a sad summer that has seen Belak, Derek Boogaard and Rick Rypien all die tragically, Modano sounded shaken.

“I am,” he said. “My initial reaction was shocked, and then you think about their families, and then you think it’s not worth it. It’s absolutely not worth it.”

The greatest American-born hockey player in the history of ever — a guy who only weeks ago had been hoping to catch on and play another season — was talking very much like a guy who is leaning toward retiring now because of a guy he did not know all that well and who played a completely different role on the ice.

“It has changed my thinking a little,” Modano admitted. “You hear about the football guys retiring with dementia, and those guys (the hockey enforcers), every day they are just pounding fist to head. They are usually the body checkers. They are probably getting the brunt of it. ...”


Remembering the many athletes sports lost way too soon.

Modano has been in two hockey fights in his life.

He started neither. He dreaded both. He lost both. He has had plenty of concussions, though, a couple of which happened before “getting your bell rung” was taken seriously — when it was seen as something real hockey players gutted out and played through. He says he is “kind of scared about what we do not know” regarding the potential long-term effects of head injuries.

Modano was careful not to link Belak’s suicide with head injuries or fighting and admits he does not know whether it should be banned. What he does know is that a lot of players he talks to are scared to find out.

“It is one thing to write about the tough-guy position in the NHL and stressors involved,” Dallas Stars general manager Joe Nieuwendyk said. “But is this what is causing guys to take their own lives? I don’t know if there is a correlation. But I know what is going to happen — people are going to write articles and talk about fighting in the NHL, and it is a slippery slope.”

Nieuwendyk played in the league for a long time and has played with one of the best tough guys in the business in Tim Hunter. So he is in no way discounting the stressors, or the toll. He talked about watching the anguish on former teammate Bill Huard’s face on days when he knew he was going to have to fight Tony Twist or somebody like him.

“We all knew, but you don’t want to say too much. It’s a tough role,” Nieuwendyk said. “There (are) a lot of questions, and who knows for sure what the answers are? I don’t know.”

Neither do I. And this is much too serious to glibly throw out solutions.

In his book “Blink,” Malcolm Gladwell says “there can be as much value in the blink of an eye as in months of rational analysis,” and that applies here.

So it is impossible to dismiss, impossible to go on watching fights and not wonder about the implications.

In 15 years, it will be impossible to ask, “How could we know?”

The answer is, “How could we not?”

It is what I wanted to ask Barch, but, when he eventually called, he said he’d rather not talk about any of the recent tragedies or speculate as to why. And who can blame him? This is how he earns a living in the league, by fighting when necessary, by doing the very thing many are speculating was the “why” in the tragic deaths of Belak, Boogaard and Rypien.

And all I know for sure is I can not look at that picture the same anymore.

Tagged: Red Wings, Stars, Predators, Mike Modano, Joe Nieuwendyk, Wade Belak, Krys Barch

More Stories From Jen Floyd Engel

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by

Play Hockey Simulation Game on WhatIfSports

More Than Sports on MSN

Fox Sports Store

    itemName itemURL imageSrc price itemDescription
    Reebok Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins Premier Hockey Jersey - Black http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Pittsburgh_Penguins/browse/featuredproduct/175178/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_175000/FF_175178_xl.jpg&w=100 159.95 Reebok Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins Premier Hockey Jersey - Black
    Reebok Dallas Stars White Premier Hockey Jersey http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Dallas_Stars/browse/featuredproduct/243363/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_243000/FF_243363_xl.jpg&w=100 124.95 Reebok Dallas Stars White Premier Hockey Jersey
    Reebok Tampa Bay Lightning Primary Logo T-Shirt - Royal Blue http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Tampa_Bay_Lightning/browse/featuredproduct/301017/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_301000/ff_301017_xl.jpg&w=100 19.95 Reebok Tampa Bay Lightning Primary Logo T-Shirt - Royal Blue
    Majestic Anaheim Ducks Black Official Logo Full Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Anaheim_Ducks/browse/featuredproduct/398322/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_398000/FF_398322_xl.jpg&w=100 43.99 Majestic Anaheim Ducks Black Official Logo Full Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt
    Detroit Red Wings Youth Black Southpaw Backpack http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Detroit_Red_Wings/browse/featuredproduct/403205/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_403000/FF_403205_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Detroit Red Wings Youth Black Southpaw Backpack
    Reebok Chicago Blackhawks #88 Patrick Kane Red Premier Hockey Jersey http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Chicago_Blackhawks/browse/featuredproduct/408123/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_408000/FF_408123_xl.jpg&w=100 159.95 Reebok Chicago Blackhawks #88 Patrick Kane Red Premier Hockey Jersey
    Majestic New Jersey Devils Red Felt Tek Patch Pullover Hoodie Sweatshirt http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_New_Jersey_Devils/browse/featuredproduct/456774/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_456000/ff_456774_xl.jpg&w=100 47.99 Majestic New Jersey Devils Red Felt Tek Patch Pullover Hoodie Sweatshirt
    Vancouver Canucks 2011 NHL Western Conference Champions Hockey Stick http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Vancouver_Canucks/browse/featuredproduct/665779/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_665000/ff_665779_xl.jpg&w=100 11.95 Vancouver Canucks 2011 NHL Western Conference Champions Hockey Stick
    Majestic New York Islanders Royal Blue Felt Tek Patch Pullover Hoodie Sweatshirt http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_New_York_Islanders/browse/featuredproduct/752594/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_752000/ff_752594_xl.jpg&w=100 47.99 Majestic New York Islanders Royal Blue Felt Tek Patch Pullover Hoodie Sweatshirt