Playoff Power Rankings: Breaking down NFL's Final Four

Share This Story

Adrian Hasenmayer

Here we go, left with one heck of an NFL Final Four with the NFL's three best teams of the 2009 season ... and then the ultimate underdog with the most brass and brash on their side.

Let's dig in and really compare how these teams stack up ...
NFL Peyton Manning_20100119195315_JPG

Colts QB Peyton Manning should have plenty of bling by the time he retires.

Andy Lyons

Breaking down the Quarterbacks

Best quarterback
1. Peyton Manning, Colts Enough about the lack of multiple Super Bowl bling. Give him time, and the NFL's king of commercials should match up with history's best quarterbacks just fine in the jewelry department. By the time he's finished his playing days and coaching up his own little Mannings, he may own every passing record in the book — even all of Brett Favre's prodigious numbers, including Mr. Wrangler's Iron-Man streak of consecutive starts.

2. Brett Favre, Vikings Having his best season ever, finally controlling his gambling urges at age 40.
3. Drew Brees, Saints The hero to those with unusual birthmarks, all the inspirational Brees is missing is a title.
4. Mark Sanchez, Jets No 23-year-old should be able to handle his success and the Big Apple madness with such ease.

  • Best arm/long ball — Brett Favre, Vikings: Even at his age, Favre can still sling it with the best of 'em.
  • Most accurate — Drew Brees, Saints: Can't argue here, since he set the NFL's all-time single-season record for completion percentage.
  • Best at reading defenses — Peyton Manning, Colts: Some joke that he's the real coach of the Colts.
  • Best pocket presence — Peyton Manning, Colts: Threw the most passes in the NFL, yet was sacked the fewest amount of times.
  • Best charisma — Brett Favre, Vikings: All four have moxie, but Favre wins for not being ashamed to throw his Wranglers on the ground.
  • Most likely to throw an INT at the worst time — Mark Sanchez, Jets: Avoiding the big picks lately, but he's still a rookie.
  • Best overall passing game — Saints: Hard to pick one among the Saints/Colts/Vikes trio, but New Orleans is loaded with X factors.

Breaking down the running backs

Best back
1. Adrian Peterson, Vikings —
This was never a question until recently, as Peterson has inexplicably struggled to hit the 100-mark recently. But talent-wise, Favre's sidekick can still go yard on any play — especially in the domed setting he'll be enjoying in New Orleans Sunday. Until Chris Johnson came along and joined the 2,000-yard club this season, Peterson was considered to be hands-down the best back in the NFL. Don't forget about him.

2. Thomas Jones, Jets —
One of the more underappreciated backs of this era, he has 2,714 rushing yards and 27 rushing TDs over the past two seasons.
3. Shonn Greene, Jets — Coming on very strong, the rookie has averaged 125.5 yards and 6.4 yards per carry in the games he's carried the rock 15 or more times.
4. Pierre Thomas, Saints — When healthy, he (not Mr. Kardashian) is the most important Saints running back.
NFL  Adrian Peterson _20100119195357_JPG

Vikings RB Adrian Peterson should play well in the dome in New Orleans.
Jonathan Daniel

  • Best home-run threat — Adrian Peterson, Vikings: Any play can be a new legendary highlight.
  • Best in space — Reggie Bush, Saints: Away from contact, may be even more dangerous than A-Pete.
  • Best on third-and-short — Thomas Jones, Jets: Seems to find a way to find the right rabbit hole.
  • Best nose for the goal line Thomas Jones, Jets: Has a real knack for hitting paydirt despite sharing goal-to-go touches.
  • Best receiving threat — Reggie Bush, Saints: Can line up inside or outside, giving Sean Payton plenty of possibilities.
  • Most likely to fumble at the worst time — Adrian Peterson, Vikings: Still must cover up with two hands in traffic.
  • Best running game — Jets: The NFL's top-ranked running game has yet to be stopped when it counts most.

Breaking down the Pass-Catchers

Best receiver
1. Reggie Wayne, Colts —
Marvin who? No disrespect to the future Hall-of-Famer Harrison, but Wayne has picked up the torch as Manning's new No. 1 in Indy without hiccup. Wayne has six straight 1,000-yard seasons, three Pro Bowls and finished with 100 catches for the second time this year as the main man for the Colts. And by the way, do you remember Wayne celebrating excessively, over-tweeting or berating his QB? How refreshing.

2. Marques Colston, Saints —
Almost as much as Brees, Colston transformed the Saints offense from the moment he arrived in mini-camp as a low-round draft pick in 2006.
3. Sidney Rice, Vikings — The third-year pro has an eery connection with Favre, as well as some startling numbers that should propel him among the league's elite young WRs.
4. Jerricho Cotchery, Jets — Doesn't have the gaudy stats thanks to the Jets' run-first attack, but no WR is tougher in the middle.

Best tight end
1. Dallas Clark, Colts —
Maybe the biggest reason why the Colts just keep on chugging in the passing game, Clark is listed as a tight end but acts more as the ultimate zone-busting wide receiver. He's got the numbers to prove his worth to the Indy attack, with 27 TD catches over his past three seasons — plus he notched a rarity for TEs, a 100-catch season this year. He is Peyton Manning's most-trusted target when he needs a first down.

2. Visanthe Shiancoe, Vikings —
Only fantasy dudes are hip to the guy with the unusual name, but Favre's secret weapon scored 11 times in 2009 while providing big-time blocking.
3. Jeremy Shockey, Saints — Still a bit injury-prone (though props for his toughness gutting it out through injury vs. the Cardinals), Shockey has turned down the hothead act since arriving in New Orleans.
4. Dustin Keller, Jets — This is no slight at all, as the kid has lots of talent and will make a Pro Bowl or two before he's done his career.

  • Best home-run threat — Percy Harvin, Vikings: Not a bad No. 2 for Minnesota, Harvin can break a big one from anywhere at any time.
  • Best hands — Reggie Wayne, Colts: Seems to find a way to find the right rabbit hole.
  • Best on third down — Dallas Clark, Colts: Seems like all his catches come on critical third downs.
  • Best in the red zone — Marques Colston, Saints: Has a real knack for hitting paydirt despite sharing goal-to-go touches.
  • Most likely to drop one at the worst time — Devery Henderson, Saints: He can be a game-changer, both in a good and bad way.
  • Best WR corps — Jets: The NFL's top-ranked running game has yet to be stopped when it counts most.

Breaking down the Offensive Lines

Best overall O-line
1. Jets —
Without arguably the NFL's most physically dominant offensive line, the Jets would probably not have reach .500 this season let alone crashed the NFC title game. The running game is predicated on wearing down opposing defenses, mostly thanks to the powerful stuff handed out by D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Nick Mangold and the gang. They are also the reason why Mark Sanchez has been able to evolve and develop throughout the season minus being scarred from getting hit too much.

2. Colts —
This no-name group must assimilate more info than most and be ready to change plans at a moment's notice with Manning behind center.
3. Vikings — Health has been an issue lately, resulting in Favre taking a few extra hits and the struggling running game. But when healthy, they are huge.
4. Saints — Brees and the offense have had few interruptions, especially thanks to unheralded guard Jahri Evans.

  • Best run-blocker — Alan Faneca, Jets: He can pound and he can pull at the heart of the physical Jets' line.
  • Best pass-blocker — Bryant McKinnie, Vikings: Had issues while playing through a bum ankle down the stretch, but erased DeMarcus Ware vs. Dallas.
  • Most physical — Steve Hutchinson, Vikings: Maybe the best guard of this generation, period.
  • Most athletic — Jahri Evans, Saints: There is really no way to get around this guy.
  • Most intense — Nick Mangold, Jets: Combines with QB Sanchez to form one of the NFL's most fiery QB-center duos.
  • Most cerebral — Jeff Saturday, Colts: Manning's long-time center must keep up with Peyton's histrionics at the line of scrimmage.
  • Most likely to brainfart at the worst time (penalty, sack allowed) — Bryant McKinnie, Vikings: For all of his skills, he has had his share of rough moments.

Breaking down the Defensive Fronts

Best overall D-line
1. Vikings —
Combine the run-stuffing ability of the "Williams Wall" with the pass-rush chaos of Jared Allen, Ray Edwards and the rest — and you have a defensive line that has the best chance to wreak havoc without having to blitz on every down. Allen brings his own special brand of madness to Minnesota, and is incredibly consistent with between 14.5-15.5 sacks in each of the past three seasons. The loss of linebacker E.J. Henderson for the season in December was a huge blow, however.

2. Colts —
The best defensive lineman in the NFL may very well be Dwight Freeney, but he's hardly alone on an incredibly fast defense.
3. Jets — The Jets would be ranked higher with DT Kris Jenkins in the lineup, but Rex Ryan's linebackers can wreak havoc.
4. Saints — The Saints can be run on and lack that elite, game-changing pass rusher.

  • Best run-stuffer —  Kevin/Pat Williams, Vikings: It's really unfair to separate one from the other, especially with how the combo has dominated running games for the past few seasons.
  • Best pass rusher — Jared Allen, Vikings: Plays like he talks, like his hair is on fire ... and that's a compliment. Freeney is a close second.
  • Best linebacker — David Harris, Jets: Outside of Darrelle Revis, Harris is New York's best player on defense.
  • Best front vs. the run — Vikings: The numbers bear this out, but the Jets are not far behind.
  • Best front vs. the pass — Jets: You rarely if ever see an opposing QB feel confortable against Rex Ryan's defense.

Breaking down the Secondaries

011910 NFL  Darrelle Revis _20100119195523_JPG

Jets cornerback Darrelle Revis has a way of shutting down receivers.
Jim McIsaac

Best overall secondary
1. Jets —
Rex Ryan said it best after the season when making the case for his guy Darrelle Revis for Defensive Player of the Year: The Jets allowed only eight touchdown passes on the entire season ... in a passing league, with 12 different QBs throwing 25-plus TD passes this season.

2. Colts —
Have you heard of Kelvin Hayden, Jerraud Powers or Melvin Bullitt? Opposing wide receivers have.
3. Saints — Remember when the Saints were a complete, utter joke in the secondary ... all of one season ago?
4. Vikings — The clear weak spot of the Vikings could cost them against Drew Brees and the Saints.

Best cornerback
1. Darrelle Revis, Jets —
The guy arguably should have won Defensive Player of the Year honors for the way he completely shuts down the best of the best big-game receivers. Randy Moss, T.O. and Ochocinco have all talked big games only to completely disappear on "Revis Island." He is the Deion Sanders of this generation.

2. Jabari Greer, Saints —
Maybe it was just a coincidence that the Saints' defense struggled with Greer injured this season? Maybe not.
3. Antoine Winfield, Vikings — He's getting up there in NFL years, but can still do it all — though maybe not quite as well as he did in the past.
4. Lito Sheppard, Jets — Didn't have the home-runs from his Philly days, but has helped shut down the other side of Revis Island.
NFL  Darren Sharper _20100119195439_JPG

Safety Darren Sharper has spearheaded the Saints defense.
Chris Graythen

Best safety
1. Darren Sharper, Saints —
Two teams have given up on him mainly due to age concerns, yet year after year Sharper continues to generate the biggest of big plays. In a way, he was the defensive Brett Favre this season — coming to a team and unit that desperately needed a spark to get his team over the hump. Sharper's nine interceptions tied for the NFL lead and spearheaded a Saints defense that finished with the second-most takeways in the league.

2. Antone Bethea, Colts —
Became a true star around the league for his ballhawking style this season in Indy.
3. Jim Leonhard, Jets — Learned the Rex Ryan approach while in Baltimore, and has assisted in spreading the defensive gospel while in New York.
4. Kerry Rhodes, Jets — Yes, he was benched during the season. But since his wake-up call, he has been a new man and playmaker.
Tagged: Bears, Cowboys, Colts, Vikings, Saints, Jets, Ravens, Cardinals, Brett Favre, Darren Sharper, Reggie Wayne, Peyton Manning, Thomas Jones, Drew Brees, Adrian Peterson, Dallas Clark, Jared Allen, Marques Colston, David Harris, Adrian Peterson, Darrelle Revis, Pierre Thomas, Mark Sanchez

More Stories From Adrian Hasenmayer

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by

NFL Videos

Best Person in Sports: Keenan Lewis Posted: Jul 15, 2014
Saints CB Keenan Lewis hosts a back-to-school event, giving children medical ser...

NFL Roundtable: New York Jets Posted: Jul 14, 2014
They're a team with plenty to prove and a roster of players primed to get it don...

NFL Roundtable: Detroit Lions Posted: Jul 11, 2014
A team with so many weapons, is this the season that the Lions put together and ...

More Than Sports on MSN