FOX Sports Exclusive
Tigers' closer situation under contol
Before Detroit Tigers fans demand that the team sign a closer, trade for a closer or kidnap a closer, they might want to consult the calendar.
It’s March 9. Opening Day is 23 days away. In a normal, non-WBC spring, the Tigers would be just starting their second week of games.
In other words, everyone calm down about Bruce Rondon.
Rondon, 22, made his fifth appearance of the spring on Friday, throwing 100 mph, throwing strikes, pitching a scoreless eighth inning against New York Mets minor-leaguers in easily his best outing of the spring.
Amazing what skipping a turn to work on your mechanics can do. Amazing what might happen if people actually let the Venezuelan rookie get through the spring, rather than rush to judgment every time he misses the plate.
I’m talking about fans panicking too soon. I’m talking about reporters tweeting breathlessly about the Tigers’ need and supposed search for a proven closer. I may also be talking about the Tigers’ manager, but Jim Leyland seemed entirely rational on the subject Friday, considering that like every veteran manager, he would prefer a 10-year All-Star at every position.
Seriously, did anyone expect the Tigers to suddenly junk the idea of Rondon as their closer after projecting him in that role for virtually the entire offseason?
Before the game, Leyland said: “I’m really not seeing anything I didn’t expect. I thought I was going to see a guy come in here and want to show everybody that he can throw hard and go after the hitters. So far, he’s thrown hard, and they’ve hit it hard. But it’s way too early to make any predictions on how that stands.”
After the game — after watching Rondon throw 15 pitches, 10 strikes, and allow two hits (one a blooper) without once getting to a three-ball count — Leyland remained decidedly in wait-and-see mode.
“He was OK,” Leyland said. “It seemed like he was under a little better control, around the plate a little bit better. He threw a couple of pitches that had excellent movement. He didn’t do anything wrong today.”
Now, I’ll grant that it’s odd for the defending American League champions, a team with a projected payroll of more than $145 million, to entrust the ninth inning to a kid who barely has pitched above Double-A.
According to STATS LLC, only three pitchers have earned saves in the World Series after beginning a season with no major league experience — Bob Welch (1978 Dodgers), Todd Worrell (1985 Cardinals) and Bobby Jenks (2005 White Sox).
If Rondon struggles early, the Tigers could allow division rivals such as the White Sox, Royals and Indians to build confidence and think big. But of course, that is just one side of the argument, and the other side is equally compelling.
No, experience is not a prerequisite for a successful closer.
As pointed out by my friend John Lowe of the Detroit Free Press, the primary closers for last year’s three NL division champions — the Nationals, Reds and Giants — had a combined five saves entering last season. Injuries created opportunities for the Nats’ Tyler Clippard, Reds’ Aroldis Chapman and Giants’ Sergio Romo.
Some sabermetricians, of course, contend that any quality reliever can close. Many baseball people disagree, but a kid with a 100 mph fastball obviously stands a better chance of fulfilling that prophesy than most.
Rondon hardly is a finished product — he threw only one breaking ball Friday, a slider. Over the next three weeks, Leyland said, he wants to see Rondon develop his secondary stuff, exhibit better overall command and throw a greater number of first-pitch strikes.
Alex Avila, the Tigers’ starting catcher, already sounds pretty sold.
“He has by far one of the best arms I’ve ever caught,” Avila said. “It’s just learning when to back off and when to reach back a little bit, being able to command.
“He can command his pitches. I’ve caught him enough in the bullpen to see he has an idea of where it’s going. He can do things with commanding his pitches that other guys who throw as hard normally can’t.”
Rondon had poor command in his early spring outings but was a different pitcher Friday, in part because of the adjustments he made at the suggestion of Tigers pitching coach Jeff Jones.
Watching video from last season, Jones noticed that Rondon was less upright in his delivery, turning more, using his legs more, staying lower to the ground.
Voila! Problem solved.
“We looked at the film, and he could see it, too, saw it right away,” Jones said. “He’s a pretty intelligent kid. He knows what he needs to do. He even said he hadn’t felt really comfortable until we worked on the side. He looked very comfortable today.”
Rondon, speaking through an interpreter, said he was grateful to Jones: “If he hadn’t told me to watch video, I wouldn’t have realized that my mechanics were kind of off.”
His day, then, amounted to a step forward. But it certainly was not the final, definitive step.
If Rondon needs more time in the minors, the Tigers could go with a closer-by-committee, choosing from among lefty Phil Coke and righties Joaquin Benoit, Al Alburquerque and Octavio Dotel. Leyland openly acknowledges that he would prefer to avoid such a thing, saying it would make his job more difficult, leaving him open to a greater amount of second-guessing.
A trade is possible — the Tigers’ chips include outfielder Brennan Bosch and the loser of the Rick Porcello/Drew Smyly fifth-starter sweepstakes. But as Leyland pointed out, more teams than ever view themselves as contenders. Late-inning relievers with those clubs generally are not available, and relievers with non-contenders cannot necessarily be trusted on a bigger stage.
The supply of bullpen arms will be more plentiful leading to the July 31 non-waiver trade deadline — and for now, the Tigers probably would be better off preserving their rotation depth, keeping both Porcello and Smyly.
It’s March 9. Plenty can happen before Opening Day, and plenty probably will. Still, kneejerk reactions run counter to the slow, steady nature of spring training.
Rondon still could prove the Tigers’ best option. Everyone calm down.
More Stories From Ken Rosenthal