Andrew McCutchen tied the game with a solo homer in the ninth inning Saturday night, then connected again in the 11th inning, rallying the struggling Pittsburgh Pirates to a 6-5 victory over the Cincinnati Reds.
"Strange game," manager Clint Hurdle said. "It’s summertime. Strange things are happening."
And some spectacular things from Pittsburgh’s best player. The Pirates blew a four-run lead for the second consecutive night, but managed to come back behind McCutchen, who has more homers against Cincinnati than anyone else since 2009.
With two swings, he saved them from another discouraging meltdown.
"Huge swings of the bat for us," Hurdle said. "He’s a special player."
The National League’s 2013 MVP tied it in the ninth off Jonathan Broxton, filling in the closer’s role because Aroldis Chapman had pitched four days in a row. McCutchen hit his 17th homer with two outs in the 11th off J.J. Hoover (1-7) for his ninth career multihomer game.
"He does a lot of unreal stuff," said left-hander Justin Wilson (3-1), who escaped a threat in the 10th. "He’s an unbelievable player. I’m glad I’m on his team and I don’t have to pitch against him."
Wilson got out of a threat in the 10th with the help of right fielder Gregory Polanco, who threw Ramon Santiago out at the plate as he tried to score from second base on Jay Bruce’s single.
"I can’t take all the credit," McCutchen said. "You’ve got to think of the throw from Polanco. That was a huge throw, a game-changer for us."
McCutchen put the Pirates back ahead with a first-pitch homer off Hoover.
"I was just ready to hit," he said. "It was a slider right down the middle, and I was ready to hit it."
Jeanmar Gomez pitched the 11th for his first career save.
"We know what they have over there," Bruce said. "A guy hits the tying and winning home runs — you don’t see that too often. I’m perfectly happy with what we did tonight, except for losing."
The Reds won the series opener 6-5 by rallying in the eighth inning against All-Star reliever Tony Watson, overcoming a four-run deficit. They pulled out of a four-run deficit again on Saturday but couldn’t finish it off.
McCutchen has 20 career homers against Cincinnati, the most by any player in the majors since 2009. He’s hit six of them this season, including three during the first two games of the series.
The Reds slipped to 7-3 on their 11-game homestand, remaining 1½ games behind NL Central co-leaders Milwaukee and St. Louis. Cincinnati is 8-4 against the Pirates this season.
Pittsburgh is 2-4 on a trip to St. Louis and Cincinnati. The Pirates gave up two game-ending homers in St. Louis and blew a four-run lead in the series opener, a 6-5 Reds win.
The Reds got in position to win it with a pair of homers.
Chris Heisey batted for Mike Leake in the sixth and hit a two-run shot off Charlie Morton. Todd Frazier — who will participate in the All-Star Home Run Derby next week — completed the comeback with a three-run shot off Morton, who had given up a total of six homers coming into the game.
All-Star Johnny Cueto (9-6) starts the final game of the series for Cincinnati. The Pirates plan to activate left-hander Francisco Liriano (1-6) off the disabled list. He has recovered from a strained oblique. … McCutchen has hit safely in 11 of the 12 games against Cincinnati this season, going 20 for 47 with four doubles, six homers and eight RBI. … The Reds optioned reliever Curtis Partch, who got the win on Friday night, to Triple-A Louisville and brought up INF Neftali Soto, giving them four position players available on the bench. … It was Heisey’s eighth career pinch-hit homer, his second this season.