MLB

Umpire controversies marring playoffs

Image: Tampa Bay Rays manager Joe Maddon argues with an umpire (Chris O'Meara/Associated Press)
Rays manager Joe Maddon was ejected after challenging a check swing call in the fifth inning....
Share This Story

Ken Rosenthal

Ken Rosenthal has been the FOXSports.com's Senior MLB Writer since August 2005. He appears weekly on MLB on FOX, FOX Sports Radio and MLB Network. He's a member of the Baseball Writers Association of America. Follow him on Twitter.

MORE>>
 
   
 

Let’s get one thing straight.

Twins right-hander Carl Pavano is to blame for allowing an RBI double to the YankeesLance Berkman on the pitch after plate umpire Hunter Wendelstedt called a ball on an apparent third strike.

Likewise, Rays right-hander Chad Qualls is to blame for allowing a three-run homer to the RangersMichael Young on the pitch after plate ump Jim Wolf ruled that Young checked his swing on a potential strike three.

Baseball games feature dozens — even hundreds — of decisive moments, not one or two. So please, no complaints from the Twins or Rays, two teams that completely gagged at home, going down two games to none.

Still, the playoffs are developing just as I feared, generating one umpiring controversy after another. And the scary part is, there does not seem to be an easy way out — no, not even through greater use of instant replay.

The initial solution, one that should be enacted no later than next postseason, is more replay and fewer umpires. But even the expansion of replay and reduction of six-man crews to four would accomplish only so much.

Baseball is getting the postseason umpires it wants now — the sport gained additional control over the selection process in its new collective-bargaining agreement with the umps.

Expanded replay, meanwhile, would not lead to reviews of every questionable call. In fact, I’m willing to bet that the next layer would not cover most of the disputed plays of the past two days — a foul tip, a trapped ball, a checked swing, a missed strike. Baseball, understandably, does not want to go too far.

Right now, I’d settle for replay on calls on the lines and calls on the bases — reviewing Buster Posey’s pivotal stolen base in the Giants’ 1-0 victory over the Braves, for example. Replay currently is used only on boundary calls on home runs.

Still, the sport would be foolish to allow blown calls — and their hotly debated aftermaths — to keep hijacking the postseason.

Over the next month, as the games grow even more meaningful, the issue only figures to get hotter.

Frankly, it’s difficult to know what to do about the umpires anymore. Baseball, as part of its new CBA with the umps, selects postseason umpires at its discretion, presumably choosing on merit, not seniority. Umpires now can work back-to-back World Series as well, though they still cannot work back-to-back postseason series in the same year.

MLB

HE DID IT!

Derek Jeter is the first Yankee to collect 3,000 hits. See the best shots from the celebration.

That’s better — a lot better than in the past. But six-man crews in the postseason are unnecessary, and dilute the umpiring talent. Twenty-four of the 68 full-time umpires — more than one-third — work the Division Series. Four-man crews with additional replay on fair/foul calls would make far more sense.

The umpires assigned to the outfield lines are not accustomed to working those positions. They invoke their lack of familiarity as an excuse when they blow calls. Trim down to 16 umps for the DS, and baseball would stand a better chance of getting the best possible group.

Such a change would be difficult to enact — baseball’s new CBA with the umpires runs through 2014. The agreement, though, grants commissioner Bud Selig the flexibility to dictate the expansion of replay. Selig could use that opening to seek a reduction of the postseason workforce, provided that he gave the umpires something in return.

Expanded replay would produce its own set of complications, but Selig no longer can say that he hears little support for the concept. Two postseason managers, the Rays’ Joe Maddon and Yankees’ Joe Girardi, publicly supported additional replay on Wednesday. The much-maligned Rays fans were chanting “re-play,” for crying out loud.

Latest from Ken Rosenthal

 

4 errors. 3 hit batsmen. 5 unearned runs. Zero chance.

Umpire controversies marring this year's playoffs

Baseball's stuck in the stone age regarding replay.

 

Right now, I’d settle for replay on calls on the lines and calls on the bases — practically anything in addition to the current replay on boundary calls on home runs.

By failing to address the issue sooner, baseball only added to the scrutiny of the umpires, creating a postseason hothouse in which every questionable call becomes a cause célèbre.

I spoke with Selig last week after my initial column on the subject, and he raised all the familiar — and understandable — reservations about replay. He also pointed out, correctly, that he introduced the wild card, interleague play and revenue sharing, among other innovations. He is not inherently resistant to change.

Well, now baseball has a problem, in some ways a problem of perception as much as anything else. This is the time of year when only the games should matter. Yet here we are, talking about the umpires, talking about replay, talking about all the wrong things.

I don’t pretend to have all the answers. I just hate seeing the sport suffer one postseason embarrassment after another.

More replay, fewer umpires. Got to start somewhere.

Tagged: Twins, Yankees, Rangers, Rays

More Stories From Ken Rosenthal

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by



SimLeague Baseball - Simulation Baseball Game

More Than Sports on MSN

Fox Sports Store

    itemName itemURL imageSrc price itemDescription
    Nike New York Yankees Practice T-Shirt - Ash http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_New_York_Yankees/browse/featuredproduct/606363/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_606000/ff_606363_xl.jpg&w=100 27.95 Nike New York Yankees Practice T-Shirt - Ash
    Majestic Detroit Tigers 2012 MLB American League Champions Clubhouse Locker Room T-Shirt - Navy Blue http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Detroit_Tigers/browse/featuredproduct/1064043/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1064000/ff_1064043_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Majestic Detroit Tigers 2012 MLB American League Champions Clubhouse Locker Room..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room T-Shirt - Gray http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_San_Francisco_Giants/browse/featuredproduct/1067359/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1067000/ff_1067359_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker R..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room Pullover Hoodie - Steel http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_San_Francisco_Giants/browse/featuredproduct/1067382/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1067000/ff_1067382_xl.jpg&w=100 54.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker R..
    New Era San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room 39THIRTY Flex Hat - Charcoal/Black http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_San_Francisco_Giants/browse/featuredproduct/1067785/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1067000/ff_1067785_xl.jpg&w=100 31.95 New Era San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Ro..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Glory T-Shirt - Black http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_San_Francisco_Giants/browse/featuredproduct/1068294/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1068000/ff_1068294_xl.jpg&w=100 21.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Glory T-Shirt - Bl..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Batting Practice Performance Jersey - Black/Orange http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_San_Francisco_Giants/browse/featuredproduct/1068787/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1068000/ff_1068787_xl.jpg&w=100 94.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Batting Practice P..