Jason Donald knows he was out

Share This Story

Jon Paul Morosi

Jon Paul Morosi is a National MLB Writer for He previously covered baseball for the Detroit Free Press and Seattle Post-Intelligencer. He began his journalism career at the Bay City Times in his native Michigan. Follow him on Twitter.



It happened in the twilight, one year ago today. A ball bounced to the right side. A pitcher and runner converged. A call was made. All hell broke loose.

Joyce, Galarraga


And the horrible calls aren't reserved for the regular season. Revisit the most egregious ump blunders of the postseason.

You can call it the Armando Galarraga Game. You can call it the Jim Joyce Game. Either way, you cannot forget the Detroit Tigers’ 3-0 victory over the Cleveland Indians on June 2, 2010.

Even the most casual sports fans can close their eyes and recount what should have been the final play of a perfect game: Tigers first baseman Miguel Cabrera ranged far to his right — maybe too far — to field Jason Donald’s tapper toward the hole. Galarraga raced over to cover first. The right-hander beat Donald there . . . caught the ball . . . stepped on the bag . . . and waited for Joyce to start the celebration with a clench of his fist.

He never did.

Joyce swept his arms to the side. Safe. Safe? The fans at Comerica Park booed — and not in a token, we-didn’t-like-that-call kind of way. They wailed with the unvarnished emotion of a child whose favorite toy had been flushed down the toilet. Cabrera, along with the rest of the country, reflexively put his hands on his head. Galarraga smiled, a graceful moment of acceptance that made him an instant media sensation.

But what about Donald?

He was playing in just his 15th major league game. His view of the play was rather simple: Once he saw Cabrera commit to fielding the ball, Donald knew that he had to win a footrace to the bag. So he did what rookies do. He put his head down and ran as fast as he could. In that sense, he would know whether Armando Galarraga had thrown a perfect game before anyone else.

“He beat me,” Donald said over the telephone Wednesday. “He had the angle. The play happened right in front of me. I knew I was out immediately.”

Except, of course, he wasn’t. Donald remembers waiting for Joyce to pump his fist — and the feeling of disbelief when he didn’t. He remembers hearing the fans go bonkers. He remembers Tigers manager Jim Leyland arguing with Joyce. He remembers staying very quiet.

Almost perfect


Eleven pitchers have lost a perfect game on the 27th batter, three on questionable calls. Two others took a perfecto into extra innings, only to lose it.

July 4, 1908, Hooks Wiltse, New York Giants: Hit batsman (Phillies pitcher George McQuillan) on a 2–2 count in a scoreless game — the only time a 0–0 perfect game has been broken up by the 27th batter. Umpire Cy Rigler later admitted that he should have called the previous pitch strike three. Wiltse won 1–0 in 10 innings — the longest complete game no-hitter, since matched twice.

Aug. 5, 1932, Tommy Bridges, Detroit Tigers: Pinch-hit single to the Washington Senators' Dave Harris.

June 27, 1958, Billy Pierce, Chicago White Sox: A double, which landed just inches in fair territory, on his first pitch to Senators pinch hitter Ed Fitz Gerald.

May 26, 1959, Harvey Haddix, Pittsburgh Pirates (37th batter): Perfect through 12. There was a throwing error in 13th, breaking up the perfect game. Following a sacrifice bunt and an intentional walk to Milwaukee Braves' Hank Aaron, Joe Adcock got the game-winning hit and Haddix took the loss.

Sept. 2, 1972, Milt Pappas, Chicago Cubs: Walked San Diego Padres pinch-hitter Larry Stahl on a borderline 3–2 pitch and finished with a no-hitter. Plate umpire, Bruce Froemming, went on to work a record 11 no-hitters. Pappas said years later that he continued to bear ill will toward Froemming.

April 15, 1983, Milt Wilcox, Tigers: Pinch-hit single to the White Sox' Jerry Hairston.

May 2, 1988, Ron Robinson, Cincinnati Reds: Single to Expos' Wallace Johnson, followed by a two-run homer to Tim Raines before being removed from the game. Robinson won 3-2.

Aug. 4, 1989, Dave Stieb, Toronto Blue Jays: Double to the Yankees' Roberto Kelly, followed by an RBI single by Steve Sax. Stieb finished with a 2–1 victory.

April 20, 1990, Brian Holman, Seattle Mariners: Home run to Ken Phelps of the Oakland Athletics.

June 3, 1995, Pedro Martinez, Montreal Expos (28th batter): Double to leadoff batter in the 10th. He then exited the game.

Sept. 2, 2001, Mike Mussina, Yankees: Two-strike single to Boston Red Sox pinch-hitter Carl Everett.

June 2, 2010, Armando Galarraga, Tigers: Infield single to Jason Donald of the Cleveland Indians. First-base umpire Jim Joyce acknowledged that he had made a bad call on the close play at first. A perfect game would have been the third in 24 days.

April 2, 2013, Yu Darvish, Rangers: Infield single to Marwin Gonzalez of the Houston Astros that went through Darvish's legs. Darvish was pulled from the game from the game after giving up the single.


Finally, as Donald walked back to the bag, Indians first base coach Sandy Alomar Jr. spoke up.

“You were out, bro,” he said.

“I know I was,” Donald replied.

By then, it was already too late. Joyce is one of the most respected umpires in baseball, a big-league veteran of more than 20 years. Donald, a major league infielder for all of two weeks, couldn’t walk over to a man of that stature and tell him that he was wrong.

Donald said he’s seen the commercial — Sportsmanship, pass it on — where the high school basketball player admits to the referee that he touched the ball before it went out of bounds. But that wasn’t the time or place to apply that lesson. In fact, Donald believes he would have sullied the game further — and caused regret for himself — by doing such a thing.

“It wouldn’t be my place to do that,” Donald says now. “It would have been disrespectful. I don’t think I could ever do that. As much as I want to argue with umpires when they call me out, I could never fight with someone who says I’m safe. I didn’t want to show him up.”

After the game, as the frenzy built in Detroit and elsewhere, the media surrounded Donald’s locker. He stayed calm. He refused to say Joyce was wrong — even though he didn’t need to see the replays to know what happened. “It was so bang-bang,” Donald said then. “I thought for sure I was going to get called out, just because of everything that was at stake.” But that’s as far as Donald went in his postgame remarks.

One year later, it’s easier for Donald to convey the emotions — complicated though they remain.

“For me, it seems like a distant memory,” he said. “I get asked about it a lot, and I have no problem answering questions. But it doesn’t cross my mind very often. I’ll see replays on TV, and I almost don’t believe it’s actually me. It’s like I’m watching some other guy run down the line.

“I knew it was a big deal when it happened. But now, I guess it’s just another part of my career, another chapter in my life. It’s not the only thing I’ve ever done or will ever do in baseball.”

Suffice it to say, though, it was the most famous of Donald’s 75 base hits last year. He has not yet added to that total in 2011.

In fact, Donald hasn’t played a game in the majors since Sept. 11. He broke his left hand during spring training, when Chicago White Sox right-hander Gavin Floyd hit him with a pitch. By April, he had returned to the minors. But Donald sustained another injury last month, when he sprained the MCL in his left knee on a takeout slide at second base by White Sox minor leaguer Gookie Dawkins.

So, one year after being involved in the season’s most famous play, Donald is spending his days at the Indians’ spring complex in suburban Phoenix, hoping his rehab work goes well enough that he can be back on the field at Class AAA a couple of weeks from now. The Indians are in first place, living a magical season no one anticipated, but Donald hasn’t been part of it yet.

In that regard, Donald is somewhat similar to Galarraga — who is also in the minors, albeit under different circumstances. Galarraga went 3-4 with a 5.91 ERA in eight starts this season with the Arizona Diamondbacks. He had a terse, unprofessional exchange with one reporter during a May 16 postgame news conference in Arizona and was cut the next day.

Galarraga is now pitching for the Diamondbacks’ Class AAA affiliate in Reno, Nev. When asked recently by the Reno Gazette-Journal why he accepted the minor-league assignment rather than become a free agent, Galarraga told the newspaper, “The money. They have to pay me $2.3 million to come here.”

Aside from Galarraga, the biggest star on that June night was Detroit center fielder Austin Jackson, whose spectacular, over-the-shoulder, warning-track catch denied Mark Grudzielanek an extra-base hit to lead off the fateful ninth. Jackson was nearly voted the American League Rookie of the Year in 2010. This year, he’s batting .224.

“It shows you how difficult baseball is,” Donald said, of the collective reversal in fortune. “It’s a humbling game. It’s a grind. All you can do is compete and try to get back to the majors. That’s what he (Galarraga) is trying to do. That’s what I’m trying to do.”


There have been 23 perfect games in MLB's history. Learn more about each masterpiece.

Donald and Galarraga haven’t spoken or faced one another since. Donald did, however, talk with Joyce later in the season, when the Indians hosted the Kansas City Royals. Joyce was umpiring at first base (again), and Donald found himself there during a pitching change. Donald wanted to check with Joyce to be sure that he had handled the situation properly, in his reaction and postgame comments.

Joyce assured Donald that he did.

“He’s a great guy,” Donald said. “He told me not to worry. He joked around a little. He just said, ‘You were doing your job. You were running as hard as you could. It’s not the guy who hit the ball. It’s the guy who made the call.’”

The Call will be analyzed and remembered for years to come, which, really, isn’t all that bad. Even on Wednesday, Cabrera admitted that he heard second baseman Carlos Guillen call for the ball himself — which, in retrospect, would have been the easier play. But Cabrera had already decided that he was going to get the ball. It was too late. So, rather than a simple 4-3, we were given one of the most debated and scrutinized plays in recent baseball history.

Donald, in fact, is among those who believe Galarraga’s achievement will be regarded as even “more special” than some of the official perfect games that have been thrown.

But ask Donald whether he considers all of this to be a happy memory, and he isn’t sure what to say.

“I wouldn’t quite say ‘happy,’” he answered, laughing a little. “It was an experience. That’s what I can say about it. At first, I didn’t appreciate the raw emotion of the Tigers’ fans. I didn’t know it was going to generate that much attention. Maybe I was naïve about that. I guess I doubted the power of the media and talk shows. I didn’t realize it was going to be such a big deal. People still talk about it.”

In the end, it comes down to a simple, silly question.

Are you glad you were safe?

“I’ve never been asked that,” Donald replied, before taking a minute to think about it.

And then he answered as any ballplayer would.

“Yeah,” he said. “I’m glad. I wanted that hit.”

Tagged: White Sox, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Miguel Cabrera, Armando Galarraga

More Stories From Jon Paul Morosi

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by

MLB Videos

Bautista talks Derek Jeter's final All-Star Game Posted: Jul 16, 2014
Jose Bautista discusses Derek Jeter's career and his final appearance in the MLB...

Jeter honored to play in last All-Star Game Posted: Jul 16, 2014
Derek Jeter compares his first All-Star Game experience with his last, Mike Trou...

Matheny defends Wainwright: He's out there to compete Posted: Jul 16, 2014
Mike Matheny comments on the media's reaction to Adam Wainwright's joke about le...

SimLeague Baseball - Simulation Baseball Game

More Than Sports on MSN

Fox Sports Store

    itemName itemURL imageSrc price itemDescription
    Nike New York Yankees Practice T-Shirt - Ash 27.95 Nike New York Yankees Practice T-Shirt - Ash
    Majestic Detroit Tigers 2012 MLB American League Champions Clubhouse Locker Room T-Shirt - Navy Blue 24.95 Majestic Detroit Tigers 2012 MLB American League Champions Clubhouse Locker Room..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room T-Shirt - Gray 24.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker R..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room Pullover Hoodie - Steel 54.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker R..
    New Era San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Room 39THIRTY Flex Hat - Charcoal/Black 31.95 New Era San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Clubhouse Locker Ro..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Glory T-Shirt - Black 21.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Glory T-Shirt - Bl..
    Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Batting Practice Performance Jersey - Black/Orange 94.95 Majestic San Francisco Giants 2012 MLB World Series Champions Batting Practice P..