World Cup

Brazil federal prosecutor challenges World Cup law

Share This Story



Brazil's federal prosecutor has challenged the constitutionality of the so-called World Cup law which was signed last year by Brazil President Dilma Rousseff.

The law gives FIFA, the world governing body of soccer, the guarantees it says it needs to organize the 2014 World Cup.

Federal prosecutor Roberto Gurgel has questioned four articles of the World Cup law. In his filing, Gurgel contends the law violates citizens' constitutional guarantee to equal treatment, as well as provisions of Brazilian tax law.

Put in place last year, the legislation was delayed several times in heated debates in Brazil's Congress, where critics argued the national government was giving FIFA too much power.

Saint-Clair Milesi, a spokesman for the local organizing committee, said there would be ''no comment on an on-going process.''

The prosecutor's office confirmed the challenge on Wednesday. The action was filed on June 17, two days after the start of the Confederations Cup - the practice event for the World Cup.

According to the filing, the World Cup law violates the constitution by requiring the state to assume civil responsibility - instead of FIFA - for any damages during the events.

''The exception given to FIFA, its subsidiaries, legal representatives, consultants and its employees manifestly violate'' the taxpayers' equal status under Brazilian law. ... ''Legislators cannot favor a taxpayer in detriment to another, but may only identify situations in which there are differences which justify different treatment.''

The two-week Confederations Cup was targeted by protesters, angry about Brazil's poor public services, education and hospitals, and upset the country is spending about $14 billion to organize the World Cup. The bill is expected to be even larger for the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Olympics.

About $3.3 billion of that money will go toward new stadiums - or remodel older ones. About 90 percent of the financing is public, although when Brazil won the bid, it said no public money would be needed to finance stadium construction.

At the height of the protests, one million people took to the streets. Protests at the six venues for the Confederations Cup were met by volleys of tear gas, shock grenades and rubber bullets.

The Confederations Cup final, won 3-0 by Brazil over Spain on June 30, was played at Rio's Maracana stadium. A security force estimated at 11,000 used tear gas outside the venue as the match was going on, with tear gas detected by fans inside the 79,000-seat venue.

The prosecutor's office said the case would be heard by Brazil's federal supreme court, though a timetable wasn't immediately made public.

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by


Nigeria reinstated by FIFA Posted: Jul 18, 2014
The Nigerian FA have been cleared by FIFA after being suspended for governmental...

Lahm retires from German national team Posted: Jul 18, 2014
World Cup champion Philipp Lahm has retired from the German national team.

Germany top FIFA rankings after winning World Cup Posted: Jul 17, 2014
Germany's fourth World Cup win has moved them to the top of FIFA's world ranking...

Pele: World Cup exit 'was a disaster' Posted: Jul 16, 2014
Brazilian legend Pele says his national team's recent losses were disastrous and...

Messi's legacy tarnished? Posted: Jul 14, 2014
Warren Barton discusses Lionel Messi's legacy after a lackluster performance in ...

More than Sports on MSN