Fantasy Football

RB committee: Evaluating every team

Share This Story

John Halpin

John Halpin has been a fantasy contributor for since 2007. He has written and co-hosted webcasts about fantasy football for, and managed websites for the NHL, the U.S. Olympic Committee and USA Network. Listen to his "Fantasy 15 Podcast" on and follow him on Twitter.


Here is our look at the backfield status for each of the NFL’s 32 teams.

Arizona Cardinals
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Tim Hightower (seven carries, 24 yards); Chris "Beanie" Wells (five carries, 19 yards; one reception, six yards)
Season: Hightower (42 carries, 229 yards, 2 TD; seven receptions, 49 yards); Wells (19 carries, 94 yards; one reception, six yards)

Comment: Wells is reportedly upset about his role with the Cardinals. He carried a bunch of times in his first appearance in Week 3, and not so much during a 41-14 blowout at the hands of the Chargers in Week 4. Shut your piehole, Beanie. You’re going to get more carries than Hightower for the rest of the season.

Atlanta Falcons
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Michael Turner (16 carries, 50 yards; three receptions, 28 yards); Jason Snelling (seven carries, 31 yards; two receptions, five yards)
Season: Turner (74 carries, 281 yards, TD; six receptions, 46 yards); Snelling (47 carries, 226 yards, 2 TD; nine receptions, 74 yards, TD)

Comment: Snelling is really getting annoying for Turner’s fantasy owners, isn’t he?

Baltimore Ravens
Committee worry level: Medium
Week 4: Willis McGahee (14 carries, 39 yards, TD; two receptions, two yards); Ray Rice (eight carries, 20 yards; one reception, nine yards)
Season: Rice (60 carries, 230 yards; 11 receptions, 74 yards); McGahee (30 carries, 76 yards, 2 TD; three receptions, minus-four yards)

Comment: Rice was probably held back a bit due to his bruised knee, but don’t worry. He should be closer to his old self this week against the Broncos. I’d probably keep McGahee benched this week.

Buffalo Bills
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Marshawn Lynch (four carries, eight yards); C.J. Spiller (two carries, 11 yards; one reception, four yards); Fred Jackson (three carries, 21 yards)
Season: Lynch (37 carries, 164 yards; one reception, seven yards); Spiller (14 carries, 49 yards; 12 receptions, 45 yards); Jackson (20 carries, 87 yards, TD; two receptions, zero yards)

Comment: With Lynch traded to the Seahawks, Jackson is now the starter, with Spiller filling the role of super-powered situational back. Both will have fantasy value, but Jackson should be in your starting lineup now.


  • Which Carolina RB will score more fantasy points for 2010?
    • Jonathan Stewart
    • DeAngelo Williams

Carolina Panthers
Committee worry level: Medium
Week 4: DeAngelo Williams (13 carries, 86 yards, TD; one reception, 14 yards); Jonathan Stewart (seven carries, 21 yards; one reception, 55 yards, TD)
Season: Williams (56 carries,246 yards; four receptions, 34 yards); Stewart (28 carries, 87 yards, TD; three receptions, 73 yards, TD)

Comment: As noted here early in the season, when Williams and Stewart are both healthy, Williams is the clear leader in the Panthers’ backfield. He’ll run a lot this week, since a few of the Bank of America Stadium popcorn vendors will probably need to start at wide receiver thanks to Steve Smith’s injury.

Chicago Bears
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Matt Forte (12 carries, 26 yards; two receptions, seven yards); Chester Taylor (three carries, 22 yards)
Season: Forte (50 carries, 134 yards; 16 receptions, 209 yards, 3 TD); Taylor (19 carries, 66 yards; five receptions, 53 yards)

Comment: Remember when I compared Forte to Marshall Faulk a few weeks ago? Can I get a mulligan on that one? His game-by-game rushing totals are 50, 29, 29 and 26. Maybe if he had an NFL-quality offensive line …

Cincinnati Bengals
Committee worry level: Non-existent
Week 4: Cedric Benson (15 carries, 60 yards); Bernard Scott (two carries, seven yards)
Season: Benson (80 carries, 262 yards, 2 TD; three receptions, 20 yards, TD); Scott (15 carries, 64 yards; three receptions, 15 yards)

Comment: When a back is this busy, you can’t bench him, no matter how mediocre he may seem sometimes. Hang in there if you own Benson.

Cleveland Browns
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Peyton Hillis (27 carries, 102 yards, TD; two receptions, eight yards); Jerome Harrison (no stats);
Season: Hillis (66 carries, 322 yards, 4 TD; 16 receptions, 94 yards); Harrison (25 carries, 85 yards; four receptions, 42 yards)

Comment: The Broncos, with no running game to speak of, traded Hillis for Brady Quinn? Really? Harrison should be dead to you at this point, unless you’re handcuffing him to Hillis in a deep league.

Dallas Cowboys
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Bye
Season: Barber (36 carries, 125 yards, TD; three receptions, six yards); Jones (22 carries, 98 yards; four receptions, 38 yards); Choice (eight carries, 21 yards; three receptions, four yards)

Comment: Jerry Jones and the coaching staff say that Jones is about to start getting busier. Let’s see it, boys.

Denver Broncos
Committee worry level: Medium
Week 4: Laurence Maroney (11 carries, five yards; two receptions, 10 yards); Correll Buckhalter (six carries, three yards; five receptions, 38 yards, TD); Knowshon Moreno (DNP - injured)
Season: Moreno (39 carries, 111 yards, 2 TD; five receptions, 71 yards); Buckhalter (27 carries, 49 yards, TD; 11 receptions, 71 yards, TD); Maroney (23 carries, 29 yards; four receptions, 50 yards)

Comment: No wonder Kyle Orton leads the league in passing attempts and yards. Jim Brown would have a hard time earning fantasy value on this team. The only one with a real chance to do so down the road is Moreno, who’s at least practicing again this week.

Detroit Lions
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Jahvid Best (12 carries, 50 yards; five receptions, 34 yards); Kevin Smith (three carries, 12 yards; four receptions, 22 yards); Maurice Morris (no stats);
Season: Best (50 carries, 174 yards, 4 TD; 21 receptions, 217 yards, TD); Morris (11 carries, 10 yards; seven receptions, 54 yards); Smith (three carries, 12 yards; four receptions, 22 yards)

Comment: Best has been a top-five running back in most formats due to all those touchdowns, but it would be nice if he ran a little better. He’s like a rich man’s Matt Forte.

Green Bay Packers
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Brandon Jackson (nine carries, 33 yards; one reception, one yard); John Kuhn (nine carries, 39 yards)
Season: Jackson (45 carries, 137 yards, TD; eight receptions, 50 yards); Kuhn (26 carries, 121 yards, TD; two receptions, 20 yards)

Comment: Can we all agree that these guys stink for fantasy purposes, even if we need to start them once in awhile? In real life, if my favorite team was a Super Bowl contender, and the GM decided to roll with this backfield situation instead of, say, dealing a couple of middle-round draft picks to the Bills for Marshawn Lynch, I’d be really PO’d.

Houston Texans
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Arian Foster (16 carries, 131 yards, TD; three receptions, 56 yards, TD); Derrick Ward (12 carries, 80 yards, TD); Steve Slaton (five carries, 37 yards; two receptions, eight yards)
Season: Foster (85 carries, 537 yards, 4 TD; 11 receptions, 152 yards, TD); Slaton (11 carries, 65 yards; nine receptions, 40 yards); Ward (14 carries, 84 yards, TD)

Comment: Ward’s newfound workload was mainly due to an early-game benching of Foster for disciplinary reasons, but he seems to be the clear option as Foster’s handcuff.

Indianapolis Colts
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Joseph Addai (16 carries, 63 yards, 2 TD; three receptions, 19 yards); Donald Brown (DNP - injured)
Season: Addai (59 carries, 228 yards, 2 TD; 13 receptions, 79 yards); Brown (23 carries, 81 yards, TD; two receptions, 26 yards)

Comment: Brown didn’t play in Week 4 due to a hamstring injury, and missed Wednesday’s practice this week. Let’s talk about him again when he’s actually on the field.

Jacksonville Jaguars
Committee worry level: Non-existent
Week 4: Maurice Jones-Drew (26 carries, 105 yards, TD; two receptions, 16 yards, TD); Rashad Jennings (three carries, six yards; two receptions, nine yards)
Season: Jones-Drew (83 carries, 322 yards, TD; eight receptions, 49 yards, TD); Jennings (19 carries, 89 yards; eight receptions, 77 yards)

Comment: It’s hard to complain about such a stellar back, but Jones-Drew averaged 50 receptions from 2006-09. Let’s pick up the pace a bit, MJD.

Kansas City Chiefs
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Bye
Season: Jones (52 carries, 216 yards, TD; two receptions, six yards); Charles (34 carries, 238 yards, TD; five receptions, 92 yards)

Comment: Gotta start both of these guys against the Colts, right?

Miami Dolphins
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Ronnie Brown (11 carries, 27 yards; four receptions, 29 yards); Ricky Williams (eight carries, 56 yards, four receptions, 45 yards, TD)
Season: Brown (48 carries, 226 yards, TD; nine receptions, 51 yards); Williams (43 carries, 165 yards, TD)

Comment: Nice to see Williams break out with a big game after his slow start. As noted here before, it’s hard to get a more even carry split than this.

Minnesota Vikings
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Bye
Season: Peterson (70 carries, 392 yards, 3 TD; 13 receptions, 85 yards); Gerhart (seven carries, 22 yards; one reception, five yards)

Comment: Will Randy Moss’ presence open up more room for Purple Jesus to run, or will Brett Favre use it as a reason to hog the spotlight and throw all the time? My brain says the former, but I fear the latter. Fortunately, Peterson will be a fantasy stud either way.

New England Patriots
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: BenJarvus Green-Ellis (16 carries, 76 yards, TD); Danny Woodhead (eight carries, 36 yards; one reception, 11 yards, TD); Sammy Morris (two carries, three yards); Fred Taylor (six carries, 16 yards)
Season: Green-Ellis (47 carries, 215 yards, 2 TD; one reception, six yards); Taylor (25 carries, 98 yards; two receptions, six yards); Woodhead (11 carries, 78 yards, TD; one reception, 11 yards, TD); Morris (nine carries, 24 yards; one reception, 19 yards)

Comment: Green-Ellis appears to be on his way to becoming a regular fantasy starter. Woodhead is now filling the Kevin Faulk role, and Faulk is a guy you never started unless you were desperate. Taylor reportedly will return after this week’s bye, so let’s not write BJGE’s name in ink just yet.

New Orleans Saints
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Ladell Betts (13 carries, 47 yards; four receptions, 23 yards); Chris Ivory (12 carries, 67 yards); Pierre Thomas (DNP - injured); Reggie Bush (DNP - injured)
Season: Thomas (46 carries, 147 yards, TD; 17 receptions, 133 yards); Ivory (19 carries, 80 yards); Bush (seven carries, 18 yards; nine receptions, 63 yards, TD); Betts (13 carries, 47 yards; four receptions, 23 yards)

Comment: Thomas is an iffy play for Week 5 after missing Wednesday’s practice. You could make a case for starting either Betts or Ivory, but probably only if you can play three backs and already have one on a bye.

New York Giants
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Ahmad Bradshaw (23 carries, 129 yards, TD; two receptions, 14 yards); Brandon Jacobs (six carries, 62 yards, TD; one reception, four yards)
Season: Bradshaw (75 carries, 382 yards, 3 TD; nine receptions, 61 yards); Jacobs (26 carries, 83 yards; four receptions, 26 yards)

Comment: I’m no fan of Jacobs, but if the Giants keep running Bradshaw this much, he’s going to wear down. Don’t say I didn’t warn you, Tom Coughlin.

New York Jets
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: LaDainian Tomlinson (19 carries, 133 yards, 2 TD; three receptions, 22 yards); Shonn Greene (22 carries, 117 yards)
Season: Tomlinson (56 carries, 341 yards, 3 TD; 12 receptions, 82 yards); Greene (52 carries, 223 yards; two receptions, 17 yards)

Comment: Told you Greene was due for a breakout! His workload wasn’t just because of the blowout win, either. He and Tomlinson shared the load, which is as it should be. LT has been solid this season, but asking for a lot of 133-yard games would be a little greedy.

Oakland Raiders
Committee worry level: Medium
Week 4: Darren McFadden (12 carries, 47 yards; six receptions, 82 yards); Michael Bush (seven carries, 40 yards, TD; two receptions, 16 yards)
Season: McFadden (85 carries, 392 yards, TD; 16 receptions, 162 yards, TD); Bush (10 carries, 53 yards, TD; two receptions, 16 yards)

Comment: McFadden won’t play this week due to a hamstring injury, which could open the door for Bush to have a nice game. But make no mistake – when McFadden is healthy, he’ll be the man.

Philadelphia Eagles
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: LeSean McCoy (16 carries, 64 yards; 12 receptions, 110 yards)
Season: McCoy (50 carries, 273 yards, 4 TD; 23 receptions, 172 yards)

Comment: McCoy get more Westbrook-esque every week, doesn’t he? His status is iffy for this week due a broken rib. Mike Bell is the backup plan.

Pittsburgh Steelers
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Rashard Mendenhall (25 carries, 79 yards, 2 TD; two receptions, nine yards); Ike Redman (one reception, six yards)
Season: Mendenhall (89 carries, 411 yards, 4 TD; five receptions, 27 yards); Redman (15 carries, 58 yards; three receptions, 18 yards)

Comment: Is there a more underrated fantasy back than Mendenhall, who is on pace for 1,752 yards from scrimmage? His touchdown runs against the Ravens were from one and seven yards. So much for Redman being the short-yardage guy.

San Diego Chargers
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Mike Tolbert (16 carries, 100 yards, TD; two receptions, three yards); Ryan Mathews (nine carries, 55 yards, TD; one reception, 13 yards); Darren Sproles (six carries, 17 yards)
Season: Tolbert (51 carries, 281 yards, TD; six receptions, 33 yards); Mathews (33 carries, 156 yards, TD; four receptions, 44 yards); Sproles (17 carries, 73 yards; seven receptions, 85 yards)

Comment: If I was a Mathews owner, I’d be terrified of those Week 4 numbers. Tolbert is too good to plant back on the bench, and Mathews was a first or second-round pick in most drafts. Yikes.

San Francisco 49ers
Committee worry level: Non-existent
Week 4: Frank Gore (21 carries, 77 yards; seven receptions, 60 yards); Anthony Dixon (one carry, three yards); Brian Westbrook (no stats)
Season: Gore (73 carries, 270 yards, TD; 29 receptions, 263 yards, TD); Westbrook (one carry, zero yards; two receptions, six yards); Dixon (two carries, five yards, TD)

Comment: I made a bet with someone that Steven Jackson would have a better fantasy season than Gore. I like Jackson a lot, but I should either write the check for $5 right now, or hire a cheap voodoo priestess to do bad things to Gore. Look at all those receptions – wow.

Seattle Seahawks
Committee worry level: Medium
Week 4: Justin Forsett (19 carries, 65 yards; two receptions, 10 yards)
Season: Forsett (51 carries, 215 yards; nine receptions, 66 yards)

Comment: When the Seahawks play again in Week 6, you should start Lynch if you have him. Let’s see what they do with Forsett before putting him back in fantasy lineups.

St. Louis Rams
Committee worry level: Non-existent
Week 4: Steven Jackson (22 carries, 70 yards; three receptions, 54 yards); Kenneth Darby (two carries, one yard; two receptions, 19 yards, TD)
Season: Jackson (73 carries, 284 yards, TD; 12 receptions, 116 yards); Darby (19 carries, 52 yards, TD; three reception, 27 yards, TD)

Comment: Jackson played pretty well for a guy with a groin injury, didn’t he? If he could only get into the end zone more often …

Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Committee worry level: High
Week 4: Bye
Season: Williams (55 carries, 139 yards; eight receptions, 64 yards); Graham (11 carries, 24 yards; 10 receptions, 98 yards, TD); Blount (six carries, 27 yards, TD)

Comment: The latest word from Tampa is that Williams’ role will be reduced, with Kareem Huggins playing more on passing downs, and Blount getting some short-yardage duty. It’s almost like some clever fantasy owner leaked this news in an effort to buy low on the Pewter Cadillac. Stay away for now.

Tennessee Titans
Committee worry level: Non-existent
Week 4: Chris Johnson (19 carries, 53 yards; three receptions, 11 yards)
Season: Johnson (94 carries, 354 yards, 4 TD; 12 receptions, 38 yards)

Comment: Did you know that Johnson has 24 fewer yards from scrimmage than Hillis? Sorry – it’s fun to tweak people when their top overall pick isn’t racking up as many fantasy points as they thought. He’s fine.

Washington Redskins
Committee worry level: Low
Week 4: Ryan Torain (18 carries, 70 yards, TD); Clinton Portis (11 carries, 55 yards; two receptions, 26 yards)
Season: Portis (49 carries, 195 yards, 2 TD; four receptions, 45 yards); Torain (25 carries, 116 yards, TD)

Comment: Portis will reportedly miss somewhere around six weeks due to his groin injury. Get on the Torain train – he’s owned in just 26.3 percent of leagues. Only practice squad refugee Keiland Williams stands between Torain and fantasy stardom.

Tagged: Michael Vick, Jay Feely, Sammy Morris, Neil Rackers, Chad Johnson, T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Phil Dawson, Joey Galloway, Jason Hanson, Donald Driver, Brett Favre, Ryan Longwell, Joe Nedney, Derrick Mason, Reggie Wayne, Peyton Manning, Tony Gonzalez, Sebastian Janikowski, Marc Bulger, Olindo Mare, Randy Moss, Tom Brady, Kevin Faulk, Adam Vinatieri, Jake Delhomme, Ricky Williams, Kerry Collins, Santana Moss, Donovan McNabb, David Akers, Correll Buckhalter, Thomas Jones, Kris Brown, Hines Ward, LaDainian Tomlinson, Drew Brees, Terrell Owens, Rian Lindell, Matt Hasselbeck, Steve Smith Sr., John Kasay, Fred Taylor, Todd Heap, Brandon Stokley, Jabar Gaffney, Deion Branch, Maurice Morris, Jeremy Shockey, Josh Reed, Clinton Portis, Antonio Bryant, David Garrard, Daniel Graham, Chester Taylor, Ladell Betts, Shayne Graham, Matt Bryant, Antwaan Randle El, Brian Westbrook, Jeff Reed, Anquan Boldin, Jason Witten, Nate Burleson, Visanthe Shiancoe, Justin Fargas, Carson Palmer, Andre Johnson, Byron Leftwich, Bryant Johnson, Willis McGahee, Dallas Clark, Larry Johnson, Kevin Walter, Josh Brown, Justin Gage, Antonio Gates, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub, Julius Jones, Devery Henderson, Larry Fitzgerald, Philip Rivers, Kellen Winslow, Roy Williams, Ben Roethlisberger, Lee Evans, Steven Jackson, Michael Jenkins, Benjamin Watson, Nate Kaeding, Bernard Berrian, Chris Cooley, Eli Manning, Derrick Ward, Patrick Crayton, Jerricho Cotchery, Mewelde Moore, Michael Turner, Lawrence Tynes, Wes Welker, Willie Parker, Earnest Graham, Malcom Floyd, Jason Wright, Mark Clayton, Aaron Rodgers, Jason Campbell, Roddy White, Heath Miller, Vincent Jackson, Frank Gore, Brandon Jones, Alex Smith, Ronnie Brown, Braylon Edwards, Cedric Benson, Carnell Williams, Troy Williamson, Dave Rayner, Derek Anderson, Matt Cassel, Kyle Orton, Marion Barber, Brandon Jacobs, Alvin Pearman, Darren Sproles, Roydell Williams, Bo Scaife, Rob Bironas, Josh Cribbs, Leonard Weaver, Nate Washington, Robbie Gould, Lance Moore, Ryan Grant, Greg Camarillo, Tarvaris Jackson, Jerious Norwood, Maurice Stovall, Reggie Bush, Vince Young, Vernon Davis, Matt Leinart, Jay Cutler, Laurence Maroney, Santonio Holmes, DeAngelo Williams, Marcedes Lewis, Joseph Addai, Kellen Clemens, Greg Jennings, Anthony Fasano, Devin Hester, Maurice Jones-Drew, Tony Scheffler, Marques Colston, Jeff King, Devin Aromashodu, Michael Robinson, Brad Smith, Jason Avant, Leon Washington, Stephen Gostkowski, Brandon Marshall, Jerome Harrison, Hank Baskett, Miles Austin, Fred Jackson, Chansi Stuckey, Kenneth Darby, Ahmad Bradshaw, Le'Ron McClain, Steve Breaston, Kevin Boss, Dante Rosario, Brent Celek, Legedu Naanee, Troy Smith, Nick Folk, Mason Crosby, Steve Smith, Brian Leonard, Jacoby Jones, Laurent Robinson, James Jones, Mike Sims-Walker, Trent Edwards, Michael Bush, Calvin Johnson, Adrian Peterson, Ted Ginn Jr., Marshawn Lynch, Brady Quinn, Dwayne Bowe, Robert Meachem, Greg Olsen, Anthony Gonzalez, Kevin Kolb, Zach Miller, Sidney Rice, Dwayne Jarrett, D.J. Ware, Matt Prater, Matt Moore, Pierre Thomas, Jonathan Stewart, Joe Flacco, Felix Jones, Rashard Mendenhall, Chris Johnson, Dustin Keller, Donnie Avery, Devin Thomas, Jordy Nelson, John Carlson, James Hardy, Eddie Royal, Matt Forte, Fred Davis, DeSean Jackson, Malcolm Kelly, Ray Rice, Chad Henne, Matt Ryan, Darren McFadden, Pierre Garcon, Chaz Schilens, Justin Forsett, Adrian Arrington, Tashard Choice, Ryan Torain, Keenan Burton, Tim Hightower, Jalen Parmele, Earl Bennett, Jamaal Charles, Early Doucet, Harry Douglas, Steve Slaton, Jermichael Finley, Mario Manningham, Davone Bess, Dan Carpenter, BenJarvus Green-Ellis, Albert Young, Garrett Hartley, Rashad Jennings, David Buehler, Javon Ringer, Cedric Peerman, Bernard Scott, Julian Edelman, Sammie Stroughter, Shonn Greene, Brandon Tate, Mike Wallace, Jared Cook, Deon Butler, Mike Thomas, Brian Hartline, Louis Murphy Jr., Austin Collie, Johnny Knox, Matthew Stafford, Mark Sanchez, Darrius Heyward-Bey, Michael Crabtree, Knowshon Moreno, Josh Freeman, Jeremy Maclin, Brandon Pettigrew, Percy Harvin, Donald Brown, Hakeem Nicks, Kenny Britt, Beanie Wells, Mohamed Massaquoi, LeSean McCoy, Arian Foster, Michael Bennett, Rob Gronkowski, Arrelious Benn, Dez Bryant, Jonathan Dwyer, Demaryius Thomas, Golden Tate, Ryan Mathews, Aaron Hernandez, Jahvid Best, Tony Moeaki, Jimmy Graham, Ed Dickson, Garrett Graham, Montario Hardesty, Dennis Pitta, Brandon LaFell, Ben Tate, Boobie Dixon, Toby Gerhart, C.J. Spiller, Sam Bradford, Jermaine Gresham, Dexter McCluster

More Stories From John Halpin

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by

More Than Sports on MSN