NCAA FB

You sure you want the Heisman, QBs?

Thayer Evans on why Andrew Luck should win Heisman Trophy.
Thayer Evans on why Andrew Luck should win Heisman Trophy.
Share This Story

Reid Forgrave

Reid Forgrave has worked for the Des Moines Register, the Cincinnati Enquirer and the Seattle Times. His work has been recognized by Associated Press Sports Editors, the Livingston Awards for Young Journalists and the Society for Features Journalism. Follow him on Twitter.

MORE>>
 
   
 

Godspeed to you, Andrew Luck. May you have a wonderful trip to New York for Saturday’s Heisman Trophy ceremony. May you accept the plaudits for your impressive college career at Stanford before you head to surefire stardom in the NFL.

Tim Tebow

WHO YA GOT?

This year's Heisman race is the closest ever. Peter Schrager predicts who he thinks will take home the trophy.

And may you return from New York empty-handed.

And you, Robert Griffin III. Congratulations for single-handedly bringing the Baylor Bears from obscurity to the 12th-ranked team in the nation. May you take your dominating season, your gaudy stats and your awesome potential to New York and enjoy the national exposure at the 77th annual Heisman ceremony. And may you also return home without a 25-pound hunk of sculpted bronze in tow.

I say this for your own good, gentlemen. Because – despite the recent NFL success of Heisman-winning quarterbacks Cam Newton, Sam Bradford and Tim Tebow – a Heisman Trophy rarely equals a winning NFL career for a quarterback. In fact, the Curse of the Heisman might even presage a pro career that’s quite the opposite.

Think a couple years of scattered Newton-Bradford-Tebow successes in the NFL disproves the Heisman curse? Be wary, young Jedis. Doubt the quarterback curse and you could end up like 2004 winner Matt Leinart, now an injured backup for the Houston Texans. (Second in Heisman voting that year? A man named Adrian Peterson.) Worse, your pro football story could go like that of Jason White, the Oklahoma quarterback who beat out Larry Fitzgerald and Eli Manning for the 2003 Heisman, then went undrafted and never played a down in the NFL. Or Chris Weinke, the 2000 Heisman winner for Florida State over Drew Brees, LaDainian Toimlinson and Michael Vick. Weinke’s NFL career started with a 1-15 rookie year as the Carolina Panthers quarterback – and went downhill from there.

There could be something at work here aside from a cosmic force that dooms the future of Heisman-winning quarterbacks. Winning an award is one thing, but truly being the best is quite another. As much as we want to think of it as the ultimate judge of a college football player, the Heisman Trophy is often no more than a popularity contest. It involves politicking and lobbying and getting the right buzz at the right time. Consider the case of Oklahoma State quarterback Brandon Weeden, who went from front-runner a few weeks ago to absolutely, positively not a chance after one double-overtime upset loss to Iowa State. The criteria for winning the Heisman Memorial Trophy involves the “pursuit of excellence with integrity ... combined with diligence, perseverance, and hard work.” It might as well read, “the player who had a great nationally televised game late in the season and got the media in a tizzy.”

It's been a rough 30 years for Heisman-winning QBs. Jim Plunkett won the Heisman Trophy as a quarterback in 1970. He went on to a memorable pro career, winning two Super Bowls with the Oakland Raiders. But since then, 17 other quarterbacks have won the Heisman. Those 17 have combined for zero Super Bowl appearances, two playoff wins and five total Pro Bowl bids. Only Doug Flutie (38-28) and Tebow (7-3) currently have winning career records. One of them (Charlie Ward) chose to pursue an NBA career instead. Two others (Crouch and White) never played a down in the NFL.

Clearly, the Heisman is as reliable of a gauge for the best football player in the country as a Pulitzer Prize is a reliable gauge for the best journalism. Sometimes, the awards are dead-on. But often times, they as much reflect lobbying on behalf of a powerful, popular institution as they do excellence or integrity. (For a stomach-churning look at this, check out the Pulitzer Prize awarded at the end of the greatest television show of all time, “The Wire.”)

There’s a different Heisman Curse that’s talked about more. It involves a shadow over the game played right after the Heisman is awarded. Heisman winners are 2-6 in the BCS National Championship Game. They’re 4-7 in bowl games since 2000, 12-17 since 1980. That’s the curse that the two Heisman finalists playing in this year’s national championship game should pay attention to: Alabama junior running back Trent Richardson and LSU sophomore cornerback Tyrann Mathieu.

So maybe, if it’s a superstitious crowd on stage at the Heisman presentation, they’ll band together and pull for the one finalist for whom neither curse applies: Wisconsin junior running back Montee Ball.

Because Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III have bright futures ahead of them. Let’s hope we’re not someday talking about them in the same breath as Gino Torretta, or Danny Wuerffel, or Andre Ware. And let’s hope their quarterbacking career leads them to brighter lights than the Omaha Nighthawks of the struggling United Football League. That was the most recent stop for Eric Crouch (2001 Heisman winner for Nebraska) and Troy Smith (2006 winner for Ohio State.)

You can follow Reid Forgrave on Twitter @reidforgrave, become a fan on Facebook or email him at reidforgrave@gmail.com.

Tagged: Iowa, Wisconsin, Stanford, Baylor, Montee Ball, Robert Griffin, Andrew Luck

More Stories From Reid Forgrave

Member Comments

Please note by clicking on "Post comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be Polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

powered by

College Football Pick'em on FOX


NCAA FB Videos

Sumlin annoyed by media's Manziel questions Posted: Jul 16, 2014
Kevin Sumlin responds to questions about life after Johnny Football by toying wi...

AJ Pasquale's journey back to UCLA Posted: Jun 17, 2014
UCLA football ops intern AJ Pasquale describes his own personal journey after th...

Winston issued adult civil citation Posted: Apr 30, 2014
Get the latest news surrounding Jameis Winston's recent shoplifting fiasco.

Get Inside the Locker Room with Scout.com

More Than Sports on MSN

Fox Sports Store

    itemName itemURL imageSrc price itemDescription
    Nike Florida Gators Gridiron 2012 Team Issue T-Shirt - Royal Blue http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Florida_Gators/browse/featuredproduct/759777/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_759000/ff_759777_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Nike Florida Gators Gridiron 2012 Team Issue T-Shirt - Royal Blue
    Nike Michigan State Spartans Football 2012 Team Issue T-Shirt - White http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Michigan_State_Spartans/browse/featuredproduct/760171/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_760000/ff_760171_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Nike Michigan State Spartans Football 2012 Team Issue T-Shirt - White
    Nike USC Trojans Fight On My School T-Shirt - Cardinal http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_USC_Trojans/browse/featuredproduct/761373/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_761000/ff_761373_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Nike USC Trojans Fight On My School T-Shirt - Cardinal
    Nike Alabama Crimson Tide Elite Force Coaches Sideline Performance Polo - Crimson http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Alabama_Crimson_Tide/browse/featuredproduct/829709/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_829000/ff_829709_xl.jpg&w=100 64.95 Nike Alabama Crimson Tide Elite Force Coaches Sideline Performance Polo - Crimso..
    Nike LSU Tigers Elite Force Coaches Sideline Performance Polo - Purple http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_LSU_Tigers/browse/featuredproduct/829740/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_829000/ff_829740_xl.jpg&w=100 49.99 Nike LSU Tigers Elite Force Coaches Sideline Performance Polo - Purple
    Nike Oklahoma Sooners Legacy 91 Dri-FIT Adjustable Coaches Cap - Crimson http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Oklahoma_Sooners/browse/featuredproduct/830935/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_830000/ff_830935_xl.jpg&w=100 21.95 Nike Oklahoma Sooners Legacy 91 Dri-FIT Adjustable Coaches Cap - Crimson
    adidas Notre Dame Fighting Irish Hot Sideline Jacket - Navy Blue http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Notre_Dame_Fighting_Irish/browse/featuredproduct/861243/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_861000/ff_861243_xl.jpg&w=100 69.95 adidas Notre Dame Fighting Irish Hot Sideline Jacket - Navy Blue
    adidas Nebraska Cornhuskers Sideline Hot Quarter Zip Jacket - Scarlet http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Nebraska_Cornhuskers/browse/featuredproduct/861247/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_861000/ff_861247_xl.jpg&w=100 69.95 adidas Nebraska Cornhuskers Sideline Hot Quarter Zip Jacket - Scarlet
    Nike Alabama Crimson Tide 2012 BCS National Champions Players Locker Room Snapback Hat - Charcoal/Black http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Alabama_Crimson_Tide/browse/featuredproduct/1087345/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1087000/ff_1087345_xl.jpg&w=100 29.95 Nike Alabama Crimson Tide 2012 BCS National Champions Players Locker Room Snapba..
    Nike Alabama Crimson Tide 2012 BCS National Champions Locker Room T-Shirt - Ash http://shop.foxsports.com/FOX_Alabama_Crimson_Tide/browse/featuredproduct/1093431/source/foxsports_prsp_ca http://images.footballfanatics.com/FFImage/thumb.aspx?i=/productImages/_1093000/ff_1093431_xl.jpg&w=100 24.95 Nike Alabama Crimson Tide 2012 BCS National Champions Locker Room T-Shirt - Ash